Index · Artikel · Tobacco health labels unconstitutional: U.S. judge

Tobacco health labels unconstitutional: U.S. judge

2012-02-29 5
   
Advertisement
résuméWASHINGTON A U.S. judge sided with tobacco companies on Wednesday, ruling that regulations requiring large graphic health warnings on cigarette packaging and advertising violate free-speech rights under the U.S. Constitution. Cigarette makers challen
Advertisement

Tobacco health labels unconstitutional: U.S. judge


WASHINGTON A U.S. judge sided with tobacco companies on Wednesday, ruling that regulations requiring large graphic health warnings on cigarette packaging and advertising violate free-speech rights under the U.S. Constitution.

Cigarette makers challenged the U.S. Food and Drug Administration's rule requiring companies to label tobacco products with images of rotting teeth, diseased lungs and other images intended to illustrate the dangers of smoking.

"The government has failed to carry both its burden of demonstrating a compelling interest and its burden of demonstrating that the rule is narrowly tailored to achieve a constitutionally permissible form of compelled commercial speech," U.S. District Judge Richard Leon said in the ruling.

The judge granted a preliminary injunction last year blocking the new label requirement from taking effect in 2012, a decision the Obama administration has already taken to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit.

The government is also likely to appeal the new ruling.

While educating the public about the dangers of smoking "might be compelling, an interest in simply advocating that the public not purchase a legal product is not," Leon wrote in a 19-page ruling.

Further, Leon noted the warning labels were too big to pass constitutional muster and that the government has numerous other tools at its disposal to deter smoking such as raising cigarette taxes or including simple factual information on the labels rather than gruesome images.

Congress passed a law in 2009 ordering the FDA to adopt the label regulation, which requires color warning labels big enough to cover the top 50 percent of a cigarette pack's front and back panels, and the top 20 percent of print advertisements.

The FDA released nine new warnings in June to go into effect in September 2012, the first change in U.S. cigarette warning labels in 25 years. Cigarette packs already carry text warnings from the U.S. Surgeon General.

Tobacco companies, including Reynolds American Inc's R.J. Reynolds unit, Lorillard Inc, Liggett Group LLC, Commonwealth Brands Inc, which is owned by Britain's Imperial Tobacco Group Plc, and Santa Fe Natural Tobacco Co Inc challenged the rule, arguing it would force them to engage in anti-smoking advocacy against their own legal products.

"Unfortunately, because Congress did not consider the First Amendment implications of this legislation, it did not concern itself with how the regulations could be narrowly tailored to avoid unintentionally compelling commercial speech," Leon wrote.

A spokesman for the Justice Department, which represented the FDA in the case, had no comment. Representatives for the tobacco companies involved in the litigation were not immediately available for comment.

Tobacco companies have said it would cost them millions of dollars to comply and also argued the graphics offer no information that could not be accomplished through messages similar to warnings already on cigarette packages and ads.

The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention estimates some 45 million adults smoke cigarettes, which are the leading cause of preventable deaths in the United States.

The ruling "ignores decades of First Amendment precedent that support the right of the government to require strong warning labels to protect the public health," Matthew Myers, president of the Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids said in a statement.

The case is R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Co et al v. FDA, U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, No. 11-1482.

(Reporting By Jeremy Pelofsky; editing by Matthew Lewis and Andre Grenon)

  • Tobacco health labels unconstitutional: U.S. judge

    Tobacco health labels unconstitutional: U.S. judge
    WASHINGTON A U.S. judge sided with tobacco companies on Wednesday, ruling that regulations requiring large graphic health warnings on cigarette packaging and advertising violate free-speech rights under the U.S. Constitution. Cigarette makers challen
    2012-02-29 USATOBACCOLABELS
  • Tobacco health labels unconstitutional: judge

    Tobacco health labels unconstitutional: judge
    WASHINGTON A U.S. judge sided with tobacco companies on Wednesday, ruling that regulations requiring large graphic health warnings on cigarette packaging and advertising violate free-speech rights under the U.S. Constitution. Cigarette makers challen
    2012-03-01 USATOBACCOLABELS
  • Obama admin appeals ruling on tobacco health label

    Obama admin appeals ruling on tobacco health label
    WASHINGTON The Obama administration on Monday appealed a decision that found unconstitutional a U.S. Food and Drug Administration regulation requiring tobacco companies to put large, graphic health warnings on cigarette packages and advertising. U.S.
    2012-03-05 USATOBACCOLABELS
  • Court: Tobacco health labels constitutional

    Court: Tobacco health labels constitutional
    n">A U.S. law requiring large graphic health warnings on cigarette packaging and advertising does not violate the free speech rights of tobacco companies, a federal appeals court ruled on Monday. Cigarette makers had sued to stop the U.S. Food and
    2012-03-19 TOBACCOLABELS
  • Judge: health labels may stem tobacco co rights

    Judge: health labels may stem tobacco co rights
    WASHINGTON A federal rule requiring large graphic health warnings on cigarette packaging and advertising may violate the free speech rights of tobacco companies, a U.S. district court judge said at a hearing on Wednesday. In a case that could wind up
    2012-02-02 USATOBACCOLABELS
  • Thailand to appeal after Philip Morris wins tobacco case

    Thailand to appeal after Philip Morris wins tobacco case
    BANGKOK The Thai government plans to appeal a court victory by tobacco giant Philip Morris to keep larger health warnings off cigarette packets for sale in Thailand. The Central Administrative Court ruled last Friday to temporarily suspend a new heal
  • Senate Republicans push health law repeal

    Senate Republicans push health law repeal
    WASHINGTON Republicans moved on Tuesday to force a U.S. Senate vote to repeal President Barack Obama's healthcare overhaul -- a day after a federal judge ruled that the law was unconstitutional. Obama's fellow Democrats in the Senate were expected to
  • Beschriften Sie einen Mental Health Patient

    Beschriften Sie einen Mental Health Patient
    Ich befürworte, dass wir das ganze Gebiet der Psychologie überdenken. Wie wir begeben sich auf ein Umdenken, was wir unter normalen meine, was wir durch die psychische Gesundheit bedeuten, und was wir meinen, durch Psychotherapie, ein erster Schritt,
    2014-07-11
  • WHO urges India to implement larger health warnings on cigarette packs

    WHO urges India to implement larger health warnings on cigarette packs
    NEW DELHI India must implement rules on printing larger health warnings on cigarette and other tobacco packs, the World Health Organization said on Wednesday, days after a parliamentary panel called for reduction in the proposed warnings size to prot
    2016-03-23 INDIATOBACCO
  • Plain cigarette packaging highlights warnings

    Plain cigarette packaging highlights warnings
    NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - A small study in England found that non-smokers and light smokers paid more attention to health warnings on cigarette packs that lacked branding graphics than on packs that included brand logos. According to the researcher
    2011-04-08 CIGARETTEPACKAGING
  • Hat Ihr Kind eine psychische Störung?

    Hat Ihr Kind eine psychische Störung?
    Anstatt davon ausgehen, dass Ihr Kind eine Pseudo-Erkrankung hat eine "psychische Störung", wenn sie traurig, ängstlich ist, oder wütend, nehme stattdessen etwas anderes. Davon aus, dass Sie nicht wissen, was los ist, und dass Sie müssen einige
    2012-03-01
  • Warum Psychologie Start Over Muss

    Warum Psychologie Start Over Muss
    Amerikanischen Psychologie entschieden sich von Verhalten der Wissenschaft zu nennen, weil das Verhalten zu beobachten (falls nicht verständlich) ist, und es schien klüger zu konzentrieren, was beobachtet werden konnte, als darüber zu spekulieren, wa
    2012-05-28
  • Was verstehen wir unter "Normal"?

    Was verstehen wir unter "Normal"?
    Es ist höchste Zeit, dass wir überdenken, was wir durch die Worte "normal" und "abnormal" bedeuten, wie diese Worte auf die mentalen und emotionalen Zuständen und Verhaltensweisen von Menschen gelten. Tatsächlich ist es eine echte Frag
    2013-04-06
  • National "Shed Ihre Depression Etikett" Day

    National "Shed Ihre Depression Etikett" Day
    Ich möchte eine nationale "Shed Ihre Depression Etikett" Tag vorzuschlagen. Wie wäre es Montag, den 12. März Jahre 2012? Sagen wir es auf unseren Kalender. An diesem Tag alle, die "eine psychische Störung, die" müde von genannt Depress
    2014-02-02
  • "Biologische" ist ein Trick Wort

    "Biologische" ist ein Trick Wort
    Alles, was ein Mensch ist hat eine biologische Komponente zu. Zu sagen, dass Ihre Atmung, Ihre Träumerei oder Ihre Aufstoßen biologischer Natur ist fügt absolut nichts zur Diskussion. Wenn ich Ihnen sagen würde: "Wissen Sie, Ihre Atmung biologisch is
    2014-08-25
  • Der Kapitalismus und Craziness

    Der Kapitalismus und Craziness
    Wenn ich eine nicht entlohnten professionelle psychische Gesundheit in einer kapitalistischen Gesellschaft (das heißt, wenn ich eine unternehmerische unabhängige professionelle in den Vereinigten Staaten bin) Ich brauche Patienten oder Kunden, um Gel
    2015-01-20
  • Der DSM-5-Kontroverse

    Der DSM-5-Kontroverse
    Ganze Abteilungen der American Psychological Association sind in die Arme über vorgeschlagene Änderungen, die in der neuen DSM-V, das herauskommt im Jahr 2013 erscheinen wird. Bereavement, was man immer schon von den affektiven Störungen ausgeschloss
    2015-08-24
  • Gewinnen Sie unendlich lang, dh!

    Gewinnen Sie unendlich lang, dh!
    World Library New, der Verleger meines neuen Buches Rethinking Depression: Wie Schuppen Mental Health Labels und erstellen persönliche Bedeutung, läuft eine kostenlose Rethinking Depression Wettbewerb , wo nur durch Eingabe Sie können meine sofort zu
    2015-11-08
  • Die Logik der Schlaflosigkeit

    Die Logik der Schlaflosigkeit
    Nach einer Princeton National Health and Wellness Survey, 37 Prozent der Erwachsenen in den USA berichtet, Schlaflosigkeit oder Schlafstörungen in den vergangenen zwölf Monaten. Zwischen 40 Prozent und 60 Prozent der Menschen im Alter von über 60 lei
    2016-02-13
  • U.S. judge upholds most limits on tobacco marketing

    U.S. judge upholds most limits on tobacco marketing
    NEW YORK A U.S. judge upheld much of a sweeping federal law limiting the marketing of cigarettes through sponsorships and on merchandise, in a ruling tobacco opponents claimed as a victory. The judge struck down some modest restrictions on color and
    2010-01-06 LAWSUITTOBACCOFDA

TOP

  • Day/
  • Week/
  • Original/
  • Recommand

Updated