Index · Artikel · Science's "most beautiful theories"

Science's "most beautiful theories"

2012-01-17 3
résuméNEW YORK From Darwinian evolution to the idea that personality is largely shaped by chance, the favorite theories of the world's most eminent thinkers are as eclectic as science itself. Every January, John Brockman, the impresario and literary agent

Science's "most beautiful theories"

NEW YORK From Darwinian evolution to the idea that personality is largely shaped by chance, the favorite theories of the world's most eminent thinkers are as eclectic as science itself.

Every January, John Brockman, the impresario and literary agent who presides over the online salon, asks his circle of scientists, digerati and humanities scholars to tackle one question.

In previous years, they have included "how is the Internet changing the way you think?" and "what is the most important invention in the last 2,000 years?"

This year, he posed the open-ended question "what is your favorite deep, elegant or beautiful explanation?"

The responses, released at midnight on Sunday, provide a crash course in science both well known and far out-of-the-box, as admired by the likes of Astronomer Royal Martin Rees, physicist Freeman Dyson and evolutionary biologist Richard Dawkins.

Several of the nearly 200 scholars nominated what are arguably the two most powerful scientific theories ever developed. "Darwin's natural selection wins hands down," argues Dawkins, emeritus professor at Oxford University.

"Never in the field of human comprehension were so many facts explained by assuming so few," he says of the theory that encompasses everything about life, based on the idea of natural selection operating on random genetic mutations.

Einstein's theory of relativity, which explains gravity as the curvature of space, also gets a few nods.

As theoretical physicist Steve Giddings of the University of California, Santa Barbara, writes, "This central idea has shaped our ideas of modern cosmology (and) given us the image of the expanding universe."

General relativity explains black holes, the bending of light and "even offers a possible explanation of the origin of our Universe - as quantum tunneling from 'nothing,'" he writes.

Many of the nominated ideas, however, won't be found in science courses taught in high school or even college.

Terrence Sejnowski, a computational neuroscientist at the Salk Institute, extols the discovery that the conscious, deliberative mind is not the author of important decisions such as what work people do and who they marry. Instead, he writes, "an ancient brain system called the basal ganglia, brain circuits that consciousness cannot access," pull the strings.

Running on the neurochemical dopamine, they predict how rewarding a choice will be - if I pick this apartment, how happy will I be? - "evaluate the current state of the entire cortex and inform the brain about the best course of action," explains Sejnowski. Only later do people construct an explanation of their choices, he said in an interview, convincing themselves incorrectly that volition and logic were responsible.

To neuroscientist Robert Sapolsky of Stanford University, the most beautiful idea is emergence, in which complex phenomena almost magically come into being from extremely simple components.

For instance, a human being arises from a few thousand genes. The intelligence of an ant colony - labor specialization, intricate underground nests - emerges from the seemingly senseless behavior of thousands of individual ants.

"Critically, there's no blueprint or central source of command," says Sapolsky. Each individual ant has a simple algorithm for interacting with the environment, "and out of this emerges a highly efficient colony."

Among other tricks, the colony has solved the notorious Traveling Salesman problem, or the challenge of stopping at a long list of destinations by the shortest route possible.


Stephen Kosslyn, director of the Center for Advanced Study in the Behavioral Sciences at Stanford, is most impressed by Pavlovian conditioning, in which a neutral stimulus such as a sound comes to be associated with a reward, such as food, producing a response, such as salivation.

That much is familiar. Less well known is that Pavlovian conditioning might account for placebo effects. After people have used analgesics such as ibuprofen or aspirin many times, the drugs begin to have effects before their active ingredients kick in.

From previous experience, the mere act of taking the pill has become like Pavlov's bell was for his dogs, causing them to salivate: the "conditioned stimulus" of merely seeing the pill "triggers the pain-relieving processes invoked by the medicine itself," explains Kosslyn.

Science theories that explain puzzling human behavior or the inner workings of the universe were also particular favorites of the Edge contributors:

* Psychologist Alison Gopnik of the University of California, Berkeley, is partial to one that accounts for why teenagers are so restless, reckless and emotional. Two brain systems, an emotional motivational system and a cognitive control system, have fallen out of sync, she explains.

The control system that inhibits impulses and allows you to delay gratification kicks in later than it did in past generations, but the motivational system is kicking in earlier and earlier.

The result: "A striking number of young adults who are enormously smart and knowledgeable but directionless, who are enthusiastic and exuberant but unable to commit to a particular work or a particular love until well into their twenties or thirties."


* Neurobiologist Sam Barondes of the University of California, San Francisco, nominates the idea that personality is largely shaped by chance. One serendipitous force is which parental genes happen to be in the egg and sperm that produced the child.

"But there is also chance in how neurodevelopmental processes unfold - a little virus here, an intrauterine event there, and you have chance all over the place," he said in an interview. Another toss of the dice: how a parent will respond to a child's genetic disposition to be outgoing, neurotic, open to new experience and the like, either reinforcing the innate tendencies or countering them.

The role of chance in creating differences between people has moral consequences, says Barondes, "promoting understanding and compassion for the wide range of people with whom we share our lives."

* Timothy Wilson nominates the idea that "people become what they do." While people's behavior arises from their character - someone returns a lost wallet because she is honest - "the reverse also holds," says the University of Virginia psychologist. If we return a lost wallet, our assessment of how honest we are rises through what he calls "self-inference." One implication of this phenomenon: "We should all heed Kurt Vonnegut's advice," Wilson says: "'We are what we pretend to be, so we must be careful about what we pretend to be.'"

* Psychologist David Myers of Hope College finds "group polarization" a beautiful idea, since it explains how interacting with others tends to amplify people's initial views. In particular, discussing issues with like-minded peers -increasingly the norm in the United States, where red states attract conservatives and blue states attract liberals - push people toward extremes. "The surprising thing is that the group as a whole becomes more extreme than its pre-discussion average," he said in an interview.

* Martin Rees, professor of cosmology and astrophysics at the University of Cambridge, nominates the "astonishing concept" that what we consider the universe "could be hugely more extensive" than what astronomers observe.

If true, the known cosmos may instead "be a tiny part of the aftermath of 'our' big bang, which is itself just one bang among a perhaps-infinite ensemble," Rees writes. Even more intriguing is that different physics might prevail in these different universes, so that "some of what we call 'laws of nature' may ... be local bylaws."

(Reporting by Sharon Begley; Editing by Michele Gershberg)


  • Day/
  • Week/
  • Original/
  • Recommand


  • Low thyroid? Maybe you're an "elephant"

    Low thyroid? Maybe you're an "elephant"
    WASHINGTON Low thyroid activity, one of the most treated conditions in the United States, may actually be a sign of longevity, researchers reported on Friday. While they said it was far too soon for people taking thyroid pills to stop, they will be l
  • Paroxysmale supraventrikuläre Tachykardien - Digoxin jemals für paroxysmale supraventicular vorgeschrieben?

    ... Tachykardien? ----schneiden---- In Antwort auf 2009-09-29 16:11 Uhr in suzanne66 Beachten Sie die folgenden Links für Ursachen, Symptome und Behandlungen von PSVT (paroxysmale supraventrikuläre Tachykardien) und Informationen über Digoxin. Digoxi
  • Orencia Nebenwirkungen?

    Ich hatte meine erste inf. letzte Thurs. (Heute ist Mo.) und ich habe nicht da wohl gefühlt. Ich dachte, es würde passieren, aber ich weiterhin das Gefühl, schlimmer wie die Zeit vergeht. Ich bin auch ein Transplantationspatient (Gallengang) und ich
  • Hassen Sie nicht die Franzia: Ein Fall für Boxed und Blended Weine

    Hassen Sie nicht die Franzia: Ein Fall für Boxed und Blended Weine
    RobotSkirts / flickr Speisen und Wein haben eine bewegte Geschichte zusammen. Aber als Nahrungs Schriftsteller überqueren ich selten die Linie. Ich kann erkennen, nur selten die Stachelbeeren, Ente Butter, Spanisch Leder und andere Aromen, die so off
  • Mensch, Natur, und Trout: Unsere Flucht Traditionen

    Mensch, Natur, und Trout: Unsere Flucht Traditionen
    Tame Fisch-und diejenigen , die fast weg-erinnern ein Angler sind , die die natürliche Welt ist unser Zuhause, ein Ort , zu verwenden und zu bewahren Die erste Forelle schlagen nicht mehr als 15 Minuten, nachdem wir zuerst unsere Linien in das Wasser
  • ADHS Diagnose Rate Bis 42 Prozent gegenüber dem letzten Jahrzehnt

    ADHS Diagnose Rate Bis 42 Prozent gegenüber dem letzten Jahrzehnt
    Die Diagnose von ADHS hat eine Menge Aufmerksamkeit der Medien in letzter Zeit über Bedenken über mögliche overdiagnosis und Übertherapie wurde immer. Eine aktuelle Studie der Centers for Disease Control (CDC) National Survey of Gesundheit von Kinder
  • Entdecken Sie das Backpulver und Zitronensaft Kombination, die Krebszellen besser als Rezept Caelyx und Adriamycin rottet

    Entdecken Sie das Backpulver und Zitronensaft Kombination, die Krebszellen besser als Rezept Caelyx und Adriamycin rottet
    Wenn Sie für eine tägliche Tonic suchen , um Ihre allgemeine Gesundheit zu verbessern und das Risiko von Krebs verringern , suchen Sie nicht weiter als eine einfache Kombination aus Zitronensaft und Backpulver. Lemon ein potenter Supernahrungsmittel
  • Als fettleibig ist besser als untergewichtig

    Als fettleibig ist besser als untergewichtig
    Die moderne Gesellschaft ist mit Gewicht besessen: jeder sehnt sich zu dünn sein, und Fettleibigkeit dämonisiert wird. Aber während Übergewicht mit sich gesundheitlichen Risiken führen nicht zu sein, eine neue Studie legt nahe , dass Untergewicht ist
  • Most Effective Alcoholism Behandlungen Defined

    Most Effective Alcoholism Behandlungen Defined
    Die massive Studie im Jahr 2006 veröffentlicht VERKNÜPFUNG folgte 1383 Patienten über einen Zeitraum von drei Jahren, um zu bestimmen, welche Kombination von Behandlung, Medikamenten und Beratung war die effektivste für die Behandlung von Alkoholmiss
  • Studie: Warum Frauen sind anfälliger für Stress

    Studie: Warum Frauen sind anfälliger für Stress
    Frauen sind häufiger von Depressionen und Stress leiden heraus als ihre kühlen männlichen Kollegen. Neue Forschung schlägt vor, könnte es einen biologischen Grund für den Unterschied zwischen den Geschlechtern sein. Die neue Studie, an Ratten durchge