Index · Artikel · Psychiatrists say diagnosis manual needs overhaul

Psychiatrists say diagnosis manual needs overhaul

2012-05-10 2
   
Advertisement
résuméLONDON Many psychiatrists believe a new edition of a manual designed to help diagnose mental illness should be shelved for at least a year for further revisions, despite some modifications which eliminated two controversial diagnoses. The new edition
Advertisement

Psychiatrists say diagnosis manual needs overhaul


LONDON Many psychiatrists believe a new edition of a manual designed to help diagnose mental illness should be shelved for at least a year for further revisions, despite some modifications which eliminated two controversial diagnoses.

The new edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM 5), a draft of which is open for public consultation this month, will be the first full revision since 1994 of the renowned handbook, which determines how to interpret symptoms in order to diagnose mental illnesses.

But more than 13,000 health professionals from around the world have already signed an open letter petition (at dsm5-reform.com) calling for DSM 5 to be halted and re-thought.

"Fundamentally, it remains a bad system," said Peter Kinderman, a professor of clinical psychology at Britain's Liverpool University.

"The very minor revisions...do not constitute the wholesale revision that is called for," he said in an emailed comment.

The American Psychiatric Association (APA), which produces the manual and plans to publish DSM 5 next May, said on Wednesday it had decided to drop two proposed diagnoses, for "attenuated psychosis syndrome" and "mixed anxiety depressive disorder".

The former, intended to help identify people at risk of full-blown psychosis, and the latter, which suggested a blend of anxiety and depression, had been criticized as too ill-defined.

With these and other new diagnoses such as "oppositional defiant disorder" and "apathy syndrome", experts said the draft DSM 5 could define as mentally ill millions of healthy people - ranging from shy or defiant children to grieving relatives, to people with harmless fetishes.

"SIMPLY NOT USABLE"

Robin Murray, a professor of psychiatric research at the Institute of Psychiatry at Kings College London, said it was a great relief to see the changes in the draft, particularly to the attenuated psychosis diagnosis.

"It would have done a lot of harm by diverting doctors into thinking about imagined risk of psychosis (and) it would have led to unnecessary fears among patients that they were about to go mad," he said in a statement.

But Allen Frances, emeritus professor at Duke University in the United States, said it was "only a first small step toward desperately needed DSM 5 reform".

"Numerous dangerous suggestions remain, Frances, who chaired a committee overseeing the DSM 4, said, adding that DSM 5 "is simply not usable" and should be delayed for an extra year "to allow for independent review, to clean up its obscure writing, and for retesting".

Diagnosis is always controversial in psychiatry, since it defines how patients will be treated based on a cluster of symptoms, many of which occur in several different types of mental illness.

Peter Jones, a professor of psychiatry at Cambridge University, said DSM 5 should be "underpinned by science" built on an understanding of the biology and functions of the brain and mind - something he said neuroscience was not yet able to do comprehensively enough.

"On this basis DSM 5 is, at best, premature and a waste of time," he said.

Some argue that the whole approach needs to be changed to pay more attention to individual circumstances rather than slotting them into predefined categories.

Lucy Johnstone, a consultant clinical psychologist for the Cwm Taf Health Board in Wales agreed: "(The DSM)is wrong in principle, based as it is on redefining a whole range of understandable reactions to life circumstances as 'illnesses', which then become a target for toxic medications heavily promoted by the pharmaceutical industry," she said.

"The DSM project cannot be justified, in principle or in practice. It must be abandoned so that we can find more humane and effective ways of responding to mental distress."

One of the proposed changes that has survived in the draft DSM 5 - despite fierce public outcry - is in autism. The new edition eliminates the milder diagnosis of Asperger syndrome in favor of the umbrella diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder.

(Editing by Myra MacDonald)

TOP

  • Day/
  • Week/
  • Original/
  • Recommand

Updated

  • Kann ich Pflege fortsetzen, während elavil für Migräne zu nehmen?

    Ich habe nur meine 11 Monate alte Baby in der Nacht Krankenschwester und haben eine schreckliche Migräne und Cluster-Kopfschmerzen, aber nicht bereit Pflege vollständig zu stoppen. Klingt wie ein Klacks weiß ich, aber sie ist meine letzte Baby und ID
  • Doctors separate conjoined twins in California

    Doctors separate conjoined twins in California
    PALO ALTO, Calif Surgeons in northern California successfully separated 2-year-old identical twin girls conjoined at the chest and abdomen after a painstaking, daylong operation, doctors said on Tuesday. Angelica and Angelina Sabuco, marked with diff
  • Wie lange vor Paxil beginnt in vollem Umfang arbeiten?

    Woche 3 von Paxil 20mg. Meine Nebenwirkungen zu Beginn waren schrecklich, Angst war schlimmer und ich konnte nicht schlafen, sitzen immer noch, renn thoughts.It der langsam fortschreitende, sehr langsam. Aber ich habe noch einige Nebenwirkungen haben
  • Medicare-Reform von Wyden, ist Paul Reform überhaupt nicht

    Medicare-Reform von Wyden, ist Paul Reform überhaupt nicht
    Die Bipartisan Optionen für die Zukunft White Paper [ PDF ] von Ron Wyden (Senat Demokrat aus Oregon) und Paul Ryan (republikanische Kongressabgeordnete aus Wisconsin) als mutigen Schritt in Rechnung gestellt Medicare zu reformieren. Es ist bewundern
  • Side Effect - Hat jemand von der Einnahme von Metformin Blasenschmerzen hatte ??

    Ich habe seit vielen Jahren Metformin genommen. Allerdings habe ich bemerkt, die Apotheke zu einem anderen "Hersteller" geändert und die Pille ist anders. Hat jemand schon einmal Blase Probleme (Schmerzen, Inkontinenz, etc.) als Nebeneffekt von
  • Warum Gesundheitswesen wird immer ein Vermögen kosten

    Warum Gesundheitswesen wird immer ein Vermögen kosten
    Hinzufügen von Kräutern zu einem Burger macht es gesünder, schlägt neue Forschung. Credit: Pam Roth / stock.xchng Konventionelle Weisheit ist seit langem , dass es bessere Länder , in denen krank zu werden als die Vereinigten Staaten, deren Gesundhei
  • Ich habe jetzt für 2 Wochen auf Bosulif worden ist, wird der Durchfall so schwer, ich denke ans Aufhören?

    Ich habe versucht, Imodium, die mit dem Durchfall hilft, aber bringt mich in die entgegengesetzte mit Verstopfung. Der Versuch, einen Mittelweg zu finden. In der Zwischenzeit versuchen, mit Schmerzen zu behandeln, Schwellungen und Blutungen. Der Appe
  • Denkbare Miracle oder Fruchtbarkeit Betrug? Wie ein Scam Spot

    Denkbare Miracle oder Fruchtbarkeit Betrug?  Wie ein Scam Spot
    Kaufen Sie Ihre IVF Medikamente online für billig! Nehmen Sie dieses All-natürliche Ergänzung und in dieser Woche vorstellen! Lesen Sie dieses Buch, und Sie werden eine Schwangerschaft Wunder haben! Schauen Sie sich diese Website für billige Medikame
  • FDA approves novel Novartis seasonal flu vaccine

    FDA approves novel Novartis seasonal flu vaccine
    n">The U.S. Food and Drug Administration said on Tuesday it approved a seasonal flu vaccine produced by Novartis using animal cell culture rather than the traditional manufacturing using chicken eggs - a speedier process that could help build stoc
  • Was bringt Sie dazu Tast Knospen zu verlieren?

    Ich habe keinen Geschmack in meinem Mund, egal wer ich esse ich es nicht schmecken. Ich habe glacoma und Dorzolamid hci ist eine meiner eyedrops. Ich wollte wissen, ob das verursacht mir nicht nichts zu schmecken. Ich seit 7 Jahren auf sie gewesen. B