Index · Artikel · Patients reluctant to disagree with doctor's advice

Patients reluctant to disagree with doctor's advice

2012-07-11 7
   
Advertisement
résuméNEW YORK (Reuters Health) - Although most people who participated in a new survey preferred making medical decisions together with their doctor, the majority said they wouldn't speak up if what they wanted conflicted with their physician's recommenda
Advertisement

Patients reluctant to disagree with doctor's advice


NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - Although most people who participated in a new survey preferred making medical decisions together with their doctor, the majority said they wouldn't speak up if what they wanted conflicted with their physician's recommendations.

The findings are based on an online panel of 1,340 adults who were told to imagine they had heart disease and were then asked about how they wanted to be involved in their own treatment.

"We know when patients are surveyed directly they really want to participate in their medical decisions, but are very nervous about this idea of pushing back against doctor recommendations for fear of being labeled a ‘bad patient,'" said Dr. Michael Barry, president of the Informed Medical Decisions Foundation and a primary care doctor at Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston.

Barry, who wasn't involved in the research but whose foundation funded it, told Reuters Health it's important for doctors to invite each patient to contribute to medical decisions - instead of believing whatever they would do for themselves is what the patient would also choose.

"It can be really tempting for doctors to think, there's only one way to go," he said.

"I think getting over that culture - that there's a right answer based as a clinician on your preferences - is what we're facing. Clinicians are the experts in the options and the outcomes of the options, but patients are experts in what's best for them."

SOCIALLY UNACCEPTABLE?

Of all the survey participants, close to 70 percent said they preferred making medical decisions together with their doctor, with each contributing equally to treatment calls.

For moderate heart disease, that can include the choice between medications, bypass surgery or angioplasty (inserting a stent) - all of which have similar long-term outcomes but come with different side effects and risks, said Dominick Frosch, from the Palo Alto Medical Foundation Research Institute and the University of California, Los Angeles.

More than 90 percent of people could envision asking their doctor questions and discussing their treatment-related preferences, Frosh and his colleagues found.

Still, just one in seven responders said they would bring up a disagreement with their doctor if the doctor's recommendation clashed with what they wanted out of their treatment. Some hypothetical patients thought disagreeing wouldn't be socially acceptable or would negatively affect their relationship with their doctor.

The study was published Monday in the Archives of Internal Medicine.

Frosch said miscommunication between doctors and patients can lead to worse outcomes, for example if patients don't take their blood pressure medications because they hadn't wanted drugs to begin with.

If that conversation about treatment options happens earlier, "it's reasonable to at least expect… perhaps patients would come out of that consultation with decisions they're more comfortable with," he said.

Along with heart disease, Frosh said patients recently diagnosed with early breast cancer or prostate cancer often have important decisions to make about treatment options, for example. "For patients, the important thing is, it would be really valuable for them to be able to speak up," Frosh told Reuters Health.

And for doctors, it comes down to "needing to create a safe space for patients to be able to speak up and express their preferences."

SOURCE: bit.ly/PM2kaj Archives of Internal Medicine, online July 9, 2012.

  • Patients reluctant to disagree with doctor's advice

    Patients reluctant to disagree with doctor's advice
    NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - Although most people who participated in a new survey preferred making medical decisions together with their doctor, the majority said they wouldn't speak up if what they wanted conflicted with their physician's recommenda
    2012-07-11 PATIENTSADVICE
  • Gene scan shows man's risk for heart attack, cancer

    Gene scan shows man's risk for heart attack, cancer
    WASHINGTON A California college professor who sequenced his own genome has had it analyzed -- and discovered he has a high risk of dropping dead of a sudden heart attack, as well as a high prostate cancer risk. The analysis, published in the Lancet m
    2010-04-30 GENESDISEASE
  • Doctors fail to cut cholesterol enough

    Doctors fail to cut cholesterol enough
    LONDON Only half of patients at high risk of heart disease are given the right targets for cutting their cholesterol and millions may suffer heart attack or stroke due to doctors' poor advice, scientists said on Thursday. German researchers said that
    2010-03-11 HEARTCHOLESTEROL
  • Debt panel eyes dual Medicare/Medicaid patients

    Debt panel eyes dual Medicare/Medicaid patients
    WASHINGTON Government health benefits for some 9 million of the sickest and poorest U.S. citizens will come under scrutiny from the congressional "super committee" seeking to cut the nation's debt. These are Americans who qualify for both the Me
  • Trauma patients taken by chopper may fare better

    Trauma patients taken by chopper may fare better
    NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - People who suffer serious injuries may have a better chance of surviving if they're taken to a trauma center by a helicopter instead of an ambulance, suggests new research. The study's lead author said he doesn't know for
  • Docs, and patients, should remember to use generics

    Docs, and patients, should remember to use generics
    n">(Reuters Health) - Prescribing generic medicines instead of brand name drugs whenever possible cuts costs, improves patient adherence and improves health outcomes, according to a new recommendation from the American College of Physicians. "
    2015-11-23 HEALTHGENERICS
  • Doctor quality ratings may be influenced by setting

    Doctor quality ratings may be influenced by setting
    n">(Reuters Health) - Patients give the same doctors different ratings depending on where their visit took place, according to a small U.S. study. Although doctors might act differently in an emergency room compared to a calmer office setting, res
  • Spinal manipulation unlikely to curb low back pain

    Spinal manipulation unlikely to curb low back pain
    NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - For people who suffer from acute low back pain, adding chiropractic spinal adjustments to standard care -- such as following your doctor's advice on managing pain and taking painkillers -- does not appear to generate a gre
    2009-08-24 SPINALMANIPULATION
  • With bad news, families often don't trust docs

    With bad news, families often don't trust docs
    NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - Families of critically ill patients may often take a more optimistic view of their loved one's condition than doctors do, even when they are given a specific estimate of the chances of survival, a new study suggests. A num
    2010-06-30 HEALTHDOCTORS
  • Families often don't trust bad news from docs

    Families often don't trust bad news from docs
    NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - Families of critically ill patients may often take a more optimistic view of their loved one's condition than doctors do, even when they are given a specific estimate of the chances of survival, a new study suggests. A num
    2010-07-01 HEALTHDOCTORS
  • Help smokers quit whether they ask or not: study

    Help smokers quit whether they ask or not: study
    NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - Doctors should automatically offer smokers help with quitting, without waiting for signs that they're ready to kick the habit, researchers say. Right now, the general guidelines for doctors say that they should ask smokers
    2012-01-11 SMOKERSQUIT
  • Helping kids be more sun-safe is a challenge: study

    Helping kids be more sun-safe is a challenge: study
    NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - Pediatricians' offices that offer more extensive counseling and information on safer sun practices are no more likely to have parents who follow that advice than offices that offer less intensive counseling, according to a
    2012-09-12 KIDSHELPING
  • Fewer heart blockages showing up on stress tests

    Fewer heart blockages showing up on stress tests
    NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - The proportion of patients who have blocked arteries show up during a stress test has dropped "enormously" over the past two decades, according to a new study. However, researchers disagreed about why that might be th
    2013-03-04 HEARTFEWERBLOCKAGES
  • Does cataract surgery make eye disease worse?

    Does cataract surgery make eye disease worse?
    NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - Cataract surgery does not appear to worsen the course of age-related macular degeneration (AMD), a progressive loss of vision due to deterioration of nerve tissue in the retina, a new study shows. The finding, however, doe
    2009-11-13 SURGERYCATARACT
  • Some 440 medical pot shops ordered to close in L.A

    Some 440 medical pot shops ordered to close in L.A
    LOS ANGELES Around 440 self-described medical marijuana dispensaries across Los Angeles were under orders to close on Monday, nearly five months after city officials voted to shut most of them down. An estimated 135 dispensaries may remain legally op
    2010-06-07 MARIJUANALOSANGELES
  • Wal-Mart worker, fired for legal pot smoking, sues

    Wal-Mart worker, fired for legal pot smoking, sues
    NEW YORK A Michigan man has sued Wal-Mart Stores Inc for firing him after he tested positive for medical marijuana he was using legally to treat pain from an inoperable brain tumor and sinus cancer. Joseph Casias, 30, said he was fired late last year
  • Rural Americans face greater lack of healthcare access

    Rural Americans face greater lack of healthcare access
    WASHINGTON A panel of health experts on Wednesday emphasized technological innovations as a way to improve healthcare in rural areas, after a study showed problems in those regions could be aggravated by new laws. The study showed rural Americans alr
    2011-07-27 RURAL
  • FDA approves Vivus's fast-acting Viagra rival

    FDA approves Vivus's fast-acting Viagra rival
    NEW YORK Men with erectile dysfunction may not have to plan for sex as far in advance anymore after Vivus Inc won U.S. approval for avanafil, its faster acting rival to Viagra. Avanafil, which will be sold under the brand name Stendra, is the first n
    2012-04-27 FDAVIVUS
  • L.A.'s richest man ups the ante for city, cancer fight

    L.A.'s richest man ups the ante for city, cancer fight
    LOS ANGELES As owner of 5 percent of the Los Angeles Lakers, Patrick Soon-Shiong could walk into the locker room of the storied basketball franchise any time for a chat with stars like Kobe Bryant. But the richest man in Los Angeles chooses to sit wi
    2012-10-03 SOONSHIONG
  • Private equity pours money into India primary healthcare

    Private equity pours money into India primary healthcare
    MUMBAI Private equity funds quadrupled their investment in India's primary healthcare, betting the sick and ailing will stop seeing family doctors in often cramped and dingy quarters and check into modern chains sprouting up across Asia's No.3 econom
    2013-01-04 INDIAHEATHCARE

TOP

  • Day/
  • Week/
  • Original/
  • Recommand

Updated

  • Hohes Cholesterin - Familial heterozygote - Ist das eine Website, dass die Menschen keine lange Zeit nicht benutzt haben?

    ... Nun, das ich um es so aussehen sieht aus wie seine gewesen 3+ Monate für jeden hier Gespräch? Bitte richten Sie mich auf eine gute und aktuelle Website, wie ich schnell erzogen werden müssen !! Vielen Dank! ----schneiden---- In Antwort auf 2010-1
  • J&J in talks to buy Synthes for $20 billion: source

    J&J in talks to buy Synthes for $20 billion: source
    BOSTON Johnson & Johnson is in preliminary talks to acquire Swiss medical device maker Synthes for a price which could be about $20 billion, a source familiar with the situation said on Saturday. A deal at that price would mark an 11 percent premium
  • Hat jemand hatte das Glück, schwanger?

    Da dieses Medikament zu nehmen, hat jemand hatte das Glück, schwanger? ----schneiden---- In Antwort auf die Marvell bei 2011-07-15 15.54 Ich kenne einige Frauen, die seit los Metformin schwanger geworden sind. Manchmal Metformin nur allein wird nicht
  • Wie Sehbehinderten Moms Watch Out für ihre Kiddies

    Wie Sehbehinderten Moms Watch Out für ihre Kiddies
    ich vermute Sie würden zustimmen, dass die Mutterschaft ist anspruchsvoll genug, auch wenn Sie in vollem Umfang gesichtet. Kinder brauchen Erwachsene, für sie zu achten 24/7, aber wie ist das möglich, wenn man nicht sehen kann, wo sie jederzeit sind
  • Optical Coherence Tomography

    Optical Coherence Tomography
    Was ist ein OCT? Optische Kohärenztomographie (OCT) ist eine nicht-invasive Abbildungstechnik verwendet, um hochauflösende Querschnittsbilder der Netzhaut erhalten. OCT ähnlich der Ultraschallprüfung, mit der Ausnahme, dass Bildgebung durch Meßlicht
  • Wie ich in diesem Sektor neu bin, würde ich gerne wissen, wie die prodution der Baumblätter zu erhöhen?

    Ich habe gerade einen kleinen Teegarten, wie es war mein Traum begann. Aber ich habe sie nicht die nötige & die ausreichende Kenntnisse in diesem Bereich. So würde Ich mag wissen, wie die Produktion increse der Baum Blätter und wie man die Bäume schn
  • Ich nehme lyrica.150mg?

    3 x pro Tag. Im vergangenen Monat habe ich zu viele und lief kurz. Der Rückzug war schrecklich. Ich dachte, ich war gonna sterben. Ich werde nie wieder passieren lassen. Ich liebe, wie lyrica mir hilft. Hat jemand anderes dieses erfahren? ----schneid
  • Wie schwierig ist es Doxepin zu stoppen?

    Ich habe über 12 Jahren auf Doxepin gewesen & Dr. will mich, es zu beenden. Jede Art von Feedback über Ihre Erfahrungen und hilfreiche Ideen würden geschätzt. Danke, Kathy ----schneiden---- In Antwort auf 2013.07.16 14.33 bis fallentim Hallo wieder,
  • Diabetes insipidus - ja meine Versicherung wird nicht mehr für DDAVP Spray bezahlen und kann nicht die Droge gehen?

    ... Und brauchen Hilfe kann nicht für Arzneimittel leisten zu zahlen und ich bin behindert und auf ein festes Einkommen und haben um Hilfe gebeten und so weit kann man kein Glück mir sagen, wer mir die Kosten für diese teuren Medikamente zur Bestreit
  • Helfen Sie irgendwelche Ideale wäre grately?

    Ich bin ein 32 Jahre alter Mann ich seit Jahren anxity gehabt haben, aber das letzte Jahr habe ich dies aber gehabt haben, dass ich Zoloft jeden Tag jeden Augenblick die dr sagte sterben werde, um zu versuchen, aber ich habe Angst, es zu den Nebenwir