Index · Artikel · Medical workers balk at mandatory flu vaccines

Medical workers balk at mandatory flu vaccines

2009-11-13 4
   
Advertisement
résuméLOS ANGELES Even as they are forced to wait like everyone else for swine flu vaccines in short supply, thousands of nurses and other front-line healthcare workers are fighting mandatory flu immunization policies being put in place by some U.S. hospit
Advertisement

Medical workers balk at mandatory flu vaccines


LOS ANGELES Even as they are forced to wait like everyone else for swine flu vaccines in short supply, thousands of nurses and other front-line healthcare workers are fighting mandatory flu immunization policies being put in place by some U.S. hospitals.

The H1N1 pandemic, which has killed about 3,900 Americans so far, has stoked tensions over the best way to safeguard medical caregivers and their patients from flu. Nurses unions have won some early battles against compulsory vaccination.

Most health experts and much of the public agree that medical personnel as a rule should be vaccinated. An infected nurse or technician can pass on a virus that could be deadly to a frail patient. But data from the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention show that only about 40 percent of U.S. healthcare workers ever get shots for seasonal influenza.

The question now dividing the medical community is whether it makes more sense to force health workers to get flu shots or to coax them into rolling up their sleeves voluntarily. Proponents of the mandatory route, adopted by a growing number of hospitals, say voluntary efforts largely have fallen short.

"They just don't work," said Dr. Neil Fishman, president-elect of the Society for Healthcare Epidemiology of America. "The bottom line is vaccination is the most effective way to prevent influenza."

He and other advocates of mandatory vaccination point to research they say shows steep declines in patient flu deaths and staff sick days when caregivers are immunized.

"This is a harm that you can prevent," said Dr. Jonathan Perlin, chief medical officer for the Tennessee-based Hospital Corporation of America (HCA), one of the leading U.S. healthcare chains. It now requires 120,000 of its employees in 21 U.S. states to get seasonal flu shots.

Critics say mandating that healthcare workers get vaccines is misguided, ineffective and ultimately counterproductive.

"There is no evidence that vaccination of healthcare workers in hospitals or outpatient settings has any impact whatsoever on patients," said Dr. Melanie Swift, head of occupational health for Vanderbilt University Medical Center in Tennessee. "You've got to vaccinate the patients."

UNION CHALLENGES

Healthcare workers unions are challenging compulsory flu vaccine policies with some success.

The University of Iowa Hospitals and Clinics was ordered to halt its mandatory program this month after unions for nearly 5,000 employees there won two binding arbitration rulings that struck down the policy as a contract violation.

Union officials note that the Iowa City facility achieved an 84 percent vaccination rate among its staff last year under its voluntary program, a level considered exemplary.

Swift said this proves the success of educating healthcare workers, some of whom have the same misconceptions and fears about vaccines as the general public. Coercion, she argued, breeds distrust that undermines government safety assurances.

Last month, a New York judge sided with a nurses union and issued a court order against a statewide policy requiring flu shots for all medical workers. Days later, the state suspended its policy, saying the flu vaccine was too scarce to enforce.

Nurses unions also have filed lawsuits against HCA hospitals on behalf of its members in California and Nevada.

Critics of mandatory immunization say the danger posed in hospitals by influenza pales in comparison to many other bugs lurking in medical facilities.

The CDC reports 1.7 million people are stricken each year by all manner of hospital-acquired infections, such as pneumonia, and 99,000 of those die. The number of flu cases among them is unknown but believed to be very small.

When flu is carried unknowingly into hospitals, unvaccinated healthcare workers are hardly the only culprits.

Hospital are filled with visitors who come into close, regular contact with patients, "and their vaccination status is almost never ascertained," Swift said.

Moreover, seasonal flu vaccines prove largely ineffective in some years against the actual strains that emerge. Thus, all other infection-control measures such as hand-washing and staying home when sick remain key to curbing flu's spread.

"It is better to be vaccinated than not vaccinated, but it doesn't preclude the need for all these other controls," Swift said. "You still have to behave the same way whether you're vaccinated or not."

(Editing by Maggie Fox and Will Dunham)

  • Medical workers balk at mandatory flu vaccines

    Medical workers balk at mandatory flu vaccines
    LOS ANGELES Even as they are forced to wait like everyone else for swine flu vaccines in short supply, thousands of nurses and other front-line healthcare workers are fighting mandatory flu immunization policies being put in place by some U.S. hospit
    2009-11-13 FLUNURSES
  • Mandatory flu shots tied to surge in health worker vaccinations

    Mandatory flu shots tied to surge in health worker vaccinations
    n">(Reuters Health) - Mandatory vaccination policies may encourage more healthcare workers to get annual flu shots and help prevent the spread of influenza to patients, a study in one Texas health system suggests. At the University of Texas MD And
  • Many health workers won't take swine flu vaccine

    Many health workers won't take swine flu vaccine
    NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - Even though testing has so far raised no "red flags" regarding safety of potential swine flu vaccines, surveys and focus groups show that healthcare workers and members of the public may be leery of being getting shot
    2009-08-27 FLUVACCINE
  • Ebola medical workers face mandatory quarantine at NYC airports

    Ebola medical workers face mandatory quarantine at NYC airports
    NEW YORK All medical workers traveling from Ebola-affected countries to New York City's airports will face a mandatory 21-day quarantine under new screening rules that exceed federal guidelines, the governors of New York and New Jersey announced on F
  • Australia rolls out nationwide swine flu vaccination

    Australia rolls out nationwide swine flu vaccination
    PERTH Australia rolled out a nationwide vaccination drive for H1N1 influenza on Wednesday in a bid to arm itself against a possible outbreak of the disease. Health Minister Nicola Roxon said 5.5 million doses of the vaccine have been delivered across
  • Swine flu vaccination effort starts Monday: CDC

    Swine flu vaccination effort starts Monday: CDC
    WASHINGTON Healthcare workers in Indiana and Tennessee will be among the first to get swine flu vaccines in the United States on Monday, the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention said. Vaccination clinics are scheduled for Monday morning fo
    2009-10-05 FLUUSAVACCINES
  • FDA approves seasonal flu vaccine

    FDA approves seasonal flu vaccine
    WASHINGTON The Food and Drug Administration approved the ordinary seasonal flu vaccine on Monday and said Americans should plan to be vaccinated. Vaccines against seasonal flu usually become available in September or October and flu experts say it is
    2009-07-20 FLUVACCINESEASONAL
  • U.S. panel to set priorities for H1N1 flu vaccines

    U.S. panel to set priorities for H1N1 flu vaccines
    WASHINGTON Vaccine experts who advise the U.S. government are likely on Wednesday to put healthcare workers, pregnant women and patients with asthma and diabetes at the front of the line to get vaccinated against the new pandemic H1N1 influenza. The
    2009-07-28 FLUVACCINEUSA
  • CSL starts U.S. swine flu vaccine trial

    CSL starts U.S. swine flu vaccine trial
    WASHINGTON CSL Ltd started testing its swine flu vaccine on U.S. children and adults on Monday, joining other companies testing the H1N1 vaccine as they also step up production. The Australian-based company said it would test 1,300 adults and 450 chi
    2009-08-24 FLUVACCINECSL
  • U.S. doubles early supply of swine flu vaccine

    U.S. doubles early supply of swine flu vaccine
    WASHINGTON U.S. health officials said on Thursday more than 6 million doses of H1N1 swine flu vaccine will be available the first week of October, twice as many as they expected only a week ago. But even as officials ramp up vaccine production, they
    2009-09-24 FLUUSA
  • People will fear flu vaccine "adverse events": study

    People will fear flu vaccine "adverse events": study
    WASHINGTON Fear of adverse events such as miscarriages, rare neurological conditions and ordinary heart attacks will discourage some people from participating in mass vaccination efforts to fight swine flu, but public health experts said on Friday th
    2009-10-30 FLUVACCINEEVENTS
  • CDC says U.S. making progress on swine flu vaccine

    CDC says U.S. making progress on swine flu vaccine
    CHICAGO U.S. health officials said on Friday they are making progress in improving the supply of H1N1 vaccine to state health departments and urged people frustrated by long lines and scarce supply not to give up. The U.S. Centers for Disease Control
    2009-11-06 FLUUSA
  • Canada shrugs off cost of flu vaccination campaign

    Canada shrugs off cost of flu vaccination campaign
    OTTAWA Canada's top medical official defended the national H1N1 vaccination campaign on Thursday, and said the costs of doing nothing would be far higher than the money spent immunizing millions of people. The Globe and Mail newspaper, citing medical
    2009-11-12 FLUCANADA
  • New seasonal flu vaccine to contain H1N1 strain

    New seasonal flu vaccine to contain H1N1 strain
    GENEVA This year's seasonal flu vaccine in the northern hemisphere should include protection against three strains, including the pandemic H1N1 virus, the World Health Organization (WHO) recommended on Thursday. The composition, announced after a fou
    2010-02-18 FLUWHO
  • Giving flu vaccine to tots cuts ER visits

    Giving flu vaccine to tots cuts ER visits
    n">Recommending that all U.S. preschoolers get a flu shot cut visits to the emergency department for flu-like illness by more than a third, U.S. and Canadian researchers said on Monday in a study that showed the direct impact of vaccination policy
    2011-09-19 FLUCHILDRENUSA
  • GlaxoSmithKline wins U.S. approval for new flu vaccine

    GlaxoSmithKline wins U.S. approval for new flu vaccine
    n">U.S. health regulators have approved a new four-strain seasonal influenza vaccine made by GlaxoSmithKline Plc, the company said on Monday. The U.S. Food and Drug Administration has approved Fluarix Quadrivalent to immunize children age 3 and ol
  • Flu vaccine not linked to fetal death

    Flu vaccine not linked to fetal death
    NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - Getting the flu vaccine while pregnant does not increase the odds that the fetus will die in the womb, according to a new study of tens of thousands of women in Norway. Although fetal deaths were rare during the study, the
    2013-01-16 FLUVACCINE
  • In U.S., flu vaccine worked in just over half of those who got it

    In U.S., flu vaccine worked in just over half of those who got it
    CHICAGO A U.S. government analysis of this season's flu vaccine suggests it was effective in only 56 percent of people who got the shot, and it largely failed to protect the elderly against an especially deadly strain circulating during flu season. T
    2013-02-21 FLUVACCINEUSA
  • Experimental bird flu vaccines show promise in early trials

    Experimental bird flu vaccines show promise in early trials
    NEW YORK/LONDON The first human tests of experimental vaccines against a deadly strain of avian flu, using novel technology that could produce millions of doses very quickly, has produced protective antibodies in the vast majority of recipients. Enco
    2013-11-14 FLUVACCINE
  • CDC says it is too late to make new flu vaccine for this season

    CDC says it is too late to make new flu vaccine for this season
    n">The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention said on Thursday it is too late to make new flu vaccines for the current flu season that could better protect against the predominant flu virus now circulating in the United States. On Wednesd
    2014-12-04 FLUCDCUSA

TOP

  • Day/
  • Week/
  • Original/
  • Recommand

Updated

  • Orabase mit Benzocain - Kann kontinuierliche Verwendung von oragel Zahnfleisch machen in eine Wunde ausbrechen?

    Gestartet den erwachsenen oragel für einen schmerzenden Zahn mit, bis ich zu Zahnarzt gehen, aber jetzt mein Zahnfleisch sind super empfindlich und brach in wie ein Kankor wund aus. Könnte es von oragel sein? ----schneiden---- In der Antwort auf Raji
  • Ist Fleisch machen uns krank? Q & A auf Veganismus, Nüsse und mehr

    Ist Fleisch machen uns krank?  Q & A auf Veganismus, Nüsse und mehr
    Ein Ernährungswissenschaftler reagiert auf Leserfragen über Fleisch und Milchprodukte (und ihre Gefahren), fragwürdige gesundheitsbezogenen Angaben und Kalorien Ich habe gerade in der Kopie bearbeitet Manuskript drehte Warum Kalorien zählen: Von der
  • Lichen sclerosus - Hat jemand in diesem Support-Gruppe haben LS auf den Oberkörper?

    Ich bin ein 53 Jahre alte Frauen und LS ist auch auf meinen Oberkörper sowie vaginal. Ich suche Unterstützung von anderen und Behandlung, die sie seit so viele Ärzte über LS leidet wissen sehr wenig nutzen. ----schneiden---- In Antwort auf 2011-10-14
  • MedCity Morgen zu lesen, Donnerstag, 26. März

    MedCity Morgen zu lesen, Donnerstag, 26. März
    US - Krankenhäuser haben einen langen Weg zu gehen , um das digitale Zeitalter zu verbinden, nach einer Umfrage veröffentlicht im New England Journal of Medicine . Nur 1,5 Prozent der fast 3.000 Krankenhäuser - etwa 44 Krankenhäuser -, die auf die Um
  • Hinweise Vom briskets Trail

    Hinweise Vom briskets Trail
    Ein Buch über Verkauf von Lebensmitteln, wie sich herausstellt, kann es sehr viel schwieriger sein , als es zu schreiben, die eine Lehre ist dieser Autor über Monate gelernt von New Haven nach Neapel verbracht reisen und zurück. Zuerst koche ich das
  • Ist es für 30yo Aortenstenose Patienten normalen Tia / Schlaganfall zu erleiden?

    Ich bin 30yo mit bikuspider Aortenstenose und Mitralinsuffizienz und erlitt einen Tia mit MRI eine Embolie zeigt. Ich habe niedrig zu regelmäßigen Blutdruck mit sauberen Arterien und keine bekannten Arrhythmie. Der Arzt sagt mir Chancen für Embolie h
  • Wie man Gewicht verlieren in einer Woche

    Wie man Gewicht verlieren in einer Woche
    Ich empfehle in der Regel nicht, dass Diät versuchen, Gewicht in einer Woche zu verlieren. Aber seien wir ehrlich - wir alle haben besondere Gelegenheiten, bei denen wir Gewicht in sieben Tagen zu verlieren brauchen, und wir werden tun, nur um etwas
  • 10 Fakten Die meisten Menschen wissen nicht, über Osteoarthritis

    10 Fakten Die meisten Menschen wissen nicht, über Osteoarthritis
    1) Osteoarthritis ist die häufigste Form von Arthritis. Sie wissen wahrscheinlich viele Menschen mit dieser Krankheit und Sie haben nicht sehr lange suchen, um sie zu finden. Arthrose betrifft 13,9% der Erwachsenen im Alter von 25 Jahre und älter und
  • Was ist eine Ehe und Familie Therapeut?

    Was ist eine Ehe und Familie Therapeut?
    Paare und Familien stehen vor besonderen Problemen, weshalb sie von der Ehe und Familie Therapeuten suchen oft Hilfe. Diese Fachleute sind geschult, speziell mit inter Fragen zu beschäftigen, die in Einzelpersonen, Paare, Familien und Gruppen entsteh
  • Wie lange bleibt Oxycodon in Ihrem System?

    Wie lange bleibt Oxycodon in Ihrem System?
    genau die Bestimmung, wie lange Oxycodon im Körper nachweisbar ist, hängt von vielen Faktoren ab, einschließlich, welche Test Art Droge verwendet wird. Oxycodon - auch bekannt als Percodan, Percocet, Tylox, OxyContin, Roxicodone, Roxicet, Endocet, Ox