Index · Artikel · Judge orders tobacco companies to admit deception

Judge orders tobacco companies to admit deception

2012-11-27 2
   
Advertisement
résuméWASHINGTON Major tobacco companies that spent decades denying they lied to the U.S. public about the dangers of cigarettes must spend their own money on a public advertising campaign saying they did lie, a federal judge ruled on Tuesday. The ruling s
Advertisement

Judge orders tobacco companies to admit deception


WASHINGTON Major tobacco companies that spent decades denying they lied to the U.S. public about the dangers of cigarettes must spend their own money on a public advertising campaign saying they did lie, a federal judge ruled on Tuesday.

The ruling sets out what might be the harshest sanction to come out of a historic case that the Justice Department brought in 1999 accusing the tobacco companies of racketeering.

U.S. District Judge Gladys Kessler wrote that the new advertising campaign would be an appropriate counterweight to the companies' "past deception" dating to at least 1964.

The advertisements are to be published in various media for as long as two years.

Details of the campaign - like how much it will cost and which media will be involved - are still to be determined and could lead to another prolonged fight.

Kessler's ruling on Tuesday, which the companies could try to appeal, aims to finalize the wording of five different statements the companies will be required to use.

One of them begins: "A federal court has ruled that the defendant tobacco companies deliberately deceived the American public by falsely selling and advertising low tar and light cigarettes as less harmful than regular cigarettes."

Another statement includes the wording: "Smoking kills, on average, 1,200 Americans. Every day."

The wording was applauded by health advocates who have waited years for tangible results from the case.

"Requiring the tobacco companies to finally tell the truth is a small price to pay for the devastating consequences of their wrongdoing," said Matthew Myers, president of the Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids, an anti-tobacco group in Washington.

The major tobacco companies, which fought having to use words like "deceived" out of concern for their free speech rights, had a muted response.

"We are reviewing the judge's ruling and considering next steps," said Bryan Hatchell, a spokesman for Reynolds American Inc.

Philip Morris USA, a unit of Altria Group Inc, is studying the decision, a spokesman said. A spokesman for a third major defendant, Lorillard Inc, had no immediate comment.

The Justice Department, which urged the strong language, was pleased with the ruling, a spokesman said.

Kessler's ruling considered whether the advertising campaign - known as "corrective statements" - would violate the companies' rights, given that the companies never agreed with her 2006 decision that they violated racketeering law.

But she concluded the statements were allowed because the final wording is "purely factual" and not controversial.

She likened the advertising campaign to other statements that U.S. officials have forced wayward companies to make.

The Federal Trade Commission, she wrote, once ordered a seller of supposed "cancer remedies" to send a letter on its own letterhead to customers telling them the commission had found its advertising to be deceptive.

"The government regularly requires wrongdoers to make similar disclosures in a number of different contexts," Kessler wrote.

Early in the long-running case, the Justice Department hoped to extract $280 billion from the companies to pay for a smoking cessation program and other remedies.

It later dropped the demand to $14 billion, and then Kessler ruled she could not force them to pay for such a program at all.

Tobacco companies are separately battling in court with the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) over the warning labels on tobacco products. The FDA has proposed new, graphic warning labels - one of which includes a photo of a man with a hole in his throat - that companies consider a free speech violation.

When Kessler first ordered the advertising campaign in 2006 - setting off six years of debate on the wording - the statements were to run on major television networks, in cigarette packaging, as full-page newspaper ads and on corporate websites.

The idea was to "structure a remedy which uses the same vehicles which defendants have themselves historically used to promulgate false smoking and health messages," she wrote then.

But in the years since, "the types of media in which defendants convey commercial messages of this nature have changed dramatically," Kessler wrote on Tuesday.

Perhaps, she added, the ads should also be in the online versions of newspapers.

The case is USA v. Philip Morris USA, et al, U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia, No. 99-cv-02496.

(Editing by Howard Goller, Gary Hill, Peter Galloway and Jim Marshall)

TOP

  • Day/
  • Week/
  • Original/
  • Recommand

Updated

  • Wie lange dauert es, für provera arbeiten Uterusblutungen zu stoppen?

    Ich bin 23 Jahre alt und wurde 7 Tage lang 10 mg Provera verschrieben, um die Blutung zu stoppen und dann einen Pap-Abstrich nehmen. Ich hatte keine Menstruation mit einer gewissen Trockenheit für mindestens 3 Monate und dann begann vor ca. 5 Monate
  • Heart failure in elderly linked to memory problems

    Heart failure in elderly linked to memory problems
    NEW YORK (Reuters Life!) - Older patients with heart failure had more memory problems when their heart ailments were advanced, but the same was not true with younger patients who suffered from a similar type of heart failure, according to a study. Th
  • Mayo Namen Development Director als neuen CEO

    Mayo Namen Development Director als neuen CEO
    Dr. John Noseworthy ROCHESTER, Minnesota â € "neue Mayo Clinic wird Chief Executive von der Entwicklung Büro kommen und Führung im November übernehmen. Dr. John Noseworthy , Neurologe und Ärztlicher Direktor der Mayo Department of Development, wird g
  • FDA staff question side effects of Regeneron gout drug

    FDA staff question side effects of Regeneron gout drug
    WASHINGTON U.S. drug reviewers said Regeneron Pharmaceuticals Inc's drug to prevent gout flares worked, but questioned its side effects and whether it did enough to help patients. The Food and Drug Administration staff on Friday said the injectable d
  • Betrug, kriminelle Geschichte hinter ALIVE in New York ausgesetzt: Joshua Daniel Scurry und Anna Marie Scurry

    Betrug, kriminelle Geschichte hinter ALIVE in New York ausgesetzt: Joshua Daniel Scurry und Anna Marie Scurry
    hat, durch Gespräche mit dem IRS sowie durch ihre Datenbank von Datensätzen bestätigt, dass weder die "ALIVE Foundation" noch "ALIVE in New York" mit dem IRS für die Annahme der Steuer absetzbar Beiträge jede rechtliche Stellung hat. D
  • Ramm über Diagnosen mit Fibromyalgie und Chronic Fatigue Syndrome

    Ramm über Diagnosen mit Fibromyalgie und Chronic Fatigue Syndrome
    Wenn Sie Fibromyalgie oder chronischem Müdigkeitssyndrom und haben nichts anderes, Sie sind beide glücklich und selten. Die meisten von uns erhalten Diagnose nach der Diagnose, und sie einfach weiter kommen. Nicht nur haben wir es mit Symptomen von m
  • Zur Vertiefung Ideen für Ihre Jugendliches

    Zur Vertiefung Ideen für Ihre Jugendliches
    Zur Vertiefung geben Sie Ihre Tweens die Gelegenheit, neue Freunde zu finden, etwas Neues zu lernen, neue Fähigkeiten zu entwickeln oder vorhandene Fähigkeiten zu verbessern und vielleicht sogar eine Leidenschaft für ein Hobby oder ein Studienfach zu
  • Kann zarelto für Kopfschmerzen w / ibuprofrn kombiniert werden, nur dieses eine Mal?

    10mg zarelto sugery19 für eine geringfügige bunion Tagen nehme, haben einen Sinus Kopfschmerzen, dass Tylenol ist nicht zu helfen ... in der Regel Ibuprofen nehmen müssen. ----schneiden---- In Antwort auf kaismama bei 2013.08.04 11.13 Nein, Sie könne
  • Die Wahrheit hinter Sugar Free Produkte

    Die Wahrheit hinter Sugar Free Produkte
    Unabhängig davon, ob Sie Diabetes haben, Essen unbegrenzte Mengen an Süßigkeiten ist nicht die beste Idee. Während Sie auf eine Behandlung von Zeit zu Zeit berechtigt sind, kann übermäßiges Essen Süßigkeiten zu steigenden Blutzucker, Bauchschmerzen u
  • Kolloidales Silber meine Heilung für fast alles!

    Kolloidales Silber meine Heilung für fast alles!
    Liebe Familie und Freunde, Ich habe meine erste Partie von kolloidalem Silber gestern. Lange Prozess es war, aber es lohnt sich. Ich bin jetzt seit einer Reihe von Jahren kolloidalem Silber wurde mit und es wurde mir kostet ein Vermögen, als ich noch