Index · Artikel · Is chocolate really heart-healthy?

Is chocolate really heart-healthy?

2012-03-02 1
   
Advertisement
résuméNEW YORK (Reuters Health) - That heart-shaped box of chocolate you got for Valentine's just might have some benefits for your real heart, a new study hints. The study, which combined the results of 42 small clinical trials, found that people fed choc
Advertisement

Is chocolate really heart-healthy?


NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - That heart-shaped box of chocolate you got for Valentine's just might have some benefits for your real heart, a new study hints.

The study, which combined the results of 42 small clinical trials, found that people fed chocolate or cocoa for a few weeks to months had small dips in their blood pressure and improved blood vessel function.

On average, chocolate eaters shaved a couple points from their blood pressure and showed a small improvement in "flow-mediated dilation" -- a measure of how well the blood vessels respond to increased blood flow.

They also had a dip in their levels of insulin, a hormone that regulates blood sugar. High insulin levels are linked to an increased risk of type 2 diabetes.

The findings, reported in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, are far from the first to connect chocolate to heart health.

A number of widely reported studies have found that chocolate lovers seem to have lower rates of certain heart risks, like high blood pressure.

But those types of studies, known as observational studies, cannot prove cause-and-effect. People who indulge in chocolate may have other factors in their lives that explain the better heart health.

In contrast, the new study focused on clinical trials -- where researchers randomly assigned people to eat chocolate or not, then watched for changes in chocolate eaters' blood pressure, cholesterol and other heart risk factors.

The fact that there were some improvements suggests that chocolate may have some actual benefits, according to the researchers, led by Lee Hooper of Norwich Medical School in the UK.

But Hooper cautioned that the studies in the analysis were small and had their flaws. And possibly most important, none have been large or long enough to show whether there's any effect on a person's risk of heart disease or stroke.

"My take-away message would be that if people like dark chocolate, then eating a little in place of other 'treat' foods is fine, and may be beneficial," Hooper told Reuters Health in an email.

"However," she added, "the evidence is not yet good enough to suggest that we should all be doing this."

An expert not involved in the study agreed.

"From a practical perspective it is premature to advise individuals to consume chocolate or cocoa to decrease their risk of cardiovascular disease," said Alice H. Lichtenstein, director of the cardiovascular nutrition lab at Tufts University in Boston.

That's due to a number of reasons, not the least of which is calorie control, according to Lichtenstein.

Another is that it's not clear how chocolate would have heart benefits. Compounds called flavonoids are the "presumed" player, Lichtenstein said in an email, but they have not been adequately tested to see whether they are, in fact, effective ways to protect your heart.

And even if they are, Lichtenstein said, "little information is available to the consumer for the level of flavonoids in a specific chocolate product."

Plus, Hooper pointed out, there's a range of plant foods that contain various flavonoids -- including many fruits (like berries, citrus and apples) and vegetables (like kale, spinach and broccoli), nuts, soy, tea and wine.

For the current study, Hooper's team pooled data from 42 small clinical trials involving about 1,300 people in all.

That approach is called a meta-analysis, and it allows researchers to draw conclusions based on bigger numbers.

But it also has shortcomings, Hooper's team acknowledges. Each of the trials was different -- including different types of people (healthy in some cases, having chronic health problems like diabetes or heart disease in others), and different ways of testing chocolate's effects.

Some studies used cocoa drinks, some solid chocolate, and some cocoa supplements. They also varied in how long people were "treated" -- but most trials lasted less than six weeks.

Larger, longer-term trials -- including ones not funded by the cocoa industry -- are needed, Hooper and her colleagues write.

Maybe the biggest question is whether any benefits would be worth the downside of chocolate. Based on these small studies, Hooper's team writes, it could take several hundred calories' worth of chocolate to see effects on insulin and blood vessel function.

And that could mean trouble for your waistline, the researchers point out.

Lichtenstein agreed. "Until we get additional data, it is premature to say that adding hot chocolate fudge sauce to a bowl of ice cream is going to decrease the risk of cardiovascular disease," she said.

"What we do know," she added, "is that adding the chocolate sauce without decreasing the amount of ice cream in the bowl is going to lead to weight gain."

For now, Lichtenstein said, if you enjoy a little chocolate in your life, you can probably keep doing so. But don't add it in the hopes of helping your heart.

SOURCE: bit.ly/wv1gCS American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, online February 1, 2012.

  • Is chocolate really heart-healthy?

    Is chocolate really heart-healthy?
    NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - That heart-shaped box of chocolate you got for Valentine's just might have some benefits for your real heart, a new study hints. The study, which combined the results of 42 small clinical trials, found that people fed choc
  • 'Healthier' chocolates gives U.S. cocoa demand a shot in the arm

    'Healthier' chocolates gives U.S. cocoa demand a shot in the arm
    NEW YORK In an increasingly diet-conscious nation where the amount of chocolate candy sold has tumbled in recent years, a niche segment of the U.S. market is taking off: so-called "healthier" chocolate. Studies declaring health benefits found in
    2013-06-03 USAHEALTHCHOCOLATE
  • Chocolate may cut cholesterol but only in some people: study

    Chocolate may cut cholesterol but only in some people: study
    NEW YORK (Reuters Life!) - Eating chocolate could bring down cholesterol levels -- but only in small amounts and only in some people, according to an analysis of eight studies. Dr. Rutai Hui of the Chinese Academy of Medical Sciences and Peking Union
  • Chocolate lovers have fewer strokes, study finds

    Chocolate lovers have fewer strokes, study finds
    NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - A sweet tooth isn't necessarily bad for your health-- at least not when it comes to chocolate, hints a new study. Researchers studying more than 33,000 Swedish women found that the more chocolate women said they ate, the l
    2011-10-10 CHOCOLATESTROKES
  • Chocolate helps you grow? EU sifts the evidence

    Chocolate helps you grow? EU sifts the evidence
    BRUSSELS A European Union committee approved more than 200 health claims Monday for use on food products, which could offer a competitive advantage to companies seeking to target health-conscious EU consumers. The final list was whittled down from ov
    2011-12-05 FOOD
  • Chocolate may be good for your heart: study

    Chocolate may be good for your heart: study
    n">Eating chocolate is not only a treat for the tongue -- it may also have some tangible benefits for heart health, such as lowering blood pressure slightly, according to a study involving more than a thousand people. The study, which combined the
    2012-03-02 HEARTCHOCOLATE
  • Chocolate lovers tend to weigh less: report

    Chocolate lovers tend to weigh less: report
    NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - In a new study, people who ate chocolate a few times per week or more weighed less than those who rarely indulged in the sweet. The finding doesn't prove that adding a candy bar to your daily diet will help you shed pounds
    2012-03-26 CHOCOLATE
  • Chocolate lovers tend to weigh less: study

    Chocolate lovers tend to weigh less: study
    n">People who ate chocolate a few times a week or more weighed less than those who rarely indulged, according to a U.S. study involving a thousand people. Researchers said the findings, published in the Archives of Internal Medicine, don't prove t
    2012-03-27 CHOCOLATE
  • Spooked by sugar, Americans search for healthier Halloween treats

    Spooked by sugar, Americans search for healthier Halloween treats
    NEW YORK The so-called war on sugar has a new battleground: Halloween. Some Americans are so spooked about the harmful effects of sugar they are finding healthier ways to indulge during the holiday, without disappointing children by handing out apple
    2015-10-30 USASUGARhalloween
  • Healthy school lunch efforts face daunting hurdles

    Healthy school lunch efforts face daunting hurdles
    LOS ANGELES School cafeteria meals like low-fat pizzas with whole grain crust don't taste too bad to Paola Villatoro, a 17-year-old at Downtown Magnet High School in Los Angeles. "Some of it is pretty good," she said. But West Adams Preparatory
    2009-05-26 HEALTHCARELUNCHES
  • Seniors stay healthier when they live with spouse

    Seniors stay healthier when they live with spouse
    NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - Elderly, community-dwelling men and women appear more likely to obtain preventive health care when they live with their spouse, as opposed to living alone or with an adult child, researchers report in the American Journal
    2009-05-29 SENIORSSPOUSE
  • Regular weigh-ins can be healthy for teens

    Regular weigh-ins can be healthy for teens
    NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - Teenagers who regularly use the bathroom scale may be more likely than their peers to take healthy measures to control their weight, a new study suggests. The findings, reported in the Journal of Adolescent Health, counter
    2009-05-29 REGULARWEIGH
  • Fewer Americans following a healthy lifestyle

    Fewer Americans following a healthy lifestyle
    NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - The number of middle-aged and older Americans who eat right, exercise and keep their weight down has declined substantially in the past two decades, a new study finds. Using data from a large government health survey, rese
    2009-06-01 FEWERLIFESTYLE
  • Healthy diet may boost men's fertility

    Healthy diet may boost men's fertility
    NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - Men who eat healthier diets may also have healthier sperm, new research from Spain shows. "A healthy, well-balanced diet is not just important for preventing diseases like diabetes, high cholesterol, or hypertension, but i
    2009-06-08 DIETFERTILITY
  • Flu drugs inappropriate for healthy adults: study

    Flu drugs inappropriate for healthy adults: study
    WASHINGTON The flu drugs Tamiflu and Relenza may not be worthwhile to treat seasonal influenza in healthy adults, British researchers reported on Friday. "Recommending the use of antiviral drugs for the treatment of people presenting with symptoms is
    2009-08-22 FLUDRUGS
  • Ein Cage-Free Chocolate Cake

    Ein Cage-Free Chocolate Cake
    Foto von Margaret Tung Black Bean Chocolate Cake, klicken Sie hier um das Rezept zu versuchen. Während ich in New York im vergangenen Sommer lebte, habe ich geschworen, als heilsam zu leben, wie ich auf dem Stipendium konnte ich als Museum intern erw
    2009-11-12
  • USDA backs rewarding schools serving healthy food

    USDA backs rewarding schools serving healthy food
    WASHINGTON Schools that serve more fruits, vegetables and whole grains to pupils should see higher federal support rates than those serving less-healthier meals loaded with high fats and sugar, Agriculture Secretary Tom Vilsack said on Tuesday. Child
    2009-11-17 USASCHOOLSNUTRITION
  • Cadbury: A Tale of Two Chocolates

    Cadbury: A Tale of Two Chocolates
    Foto von Jerine / FlickrCC Als ich in England aufwuchs war während der letzten Stadien des Zweiten Weltkriegs, sehr wenig Schokolade auf die durchschnittliche Person. Wie alle Süßigkeiten, mit Ausnahme von Bullaugen Pfefferminze Saugern wurde rationi
    2010-01-21
  • "Club drug" ecstasy risky for healthy youth

    "Club drug" ecstasy risky for healthy youth
    LONDON The so-called "club drug" ecstasy is more likely than other stimulants like speed or crystal meth to kill young, healthy people who are not known as regular drug users, British researchers said on Friday. A study of stimulant-deaths in Br
    2010-01-29 DRUGSECSTASY
  • Jeder Tag ist Hot Chocolate Day

    Jeder Tag ist Hot Chocolate Day
    Foto von niseag03 / FlickrCC Zekes Post hat mich nehmen Lager der Zahl der Marken von heißem Kakao und heiße Schokolade mischt ich in meiner ständigen Rotation haben. Es war neun, nicht auf die drei Marken von Kakaopulver zählen die ich habe. Es lohn
    2010-02-18

TOP

  • Day/
  • Week/
  • Original/
  • Recommand

Updated

  • Sedatives may increase elderly suicide risk: study

    Sedatives may increase elderly suicide risk: study
    LONDON Sedatives and sleeping pills prescribed to ease depression, anxiety and sleep problems appear to increase the risk of suicide four-fold among the elderly, Swedish researchers said on Wednesday. A review of elderly Suicides in the Swedish city
  • Hat Kamagra die gleiche wie Marke Viagra handeln?

    Ich fand, dass Kamagra enthält Sildenafil Citrat und Viagra enthält es auch. Kann ich Kamagra für ED verwenden? ----schneiden---- In Antwort auf die Marvell bei 2010-02-14 14.38 Kamagra ist kein registrierter Medizin in Vereinigten Staaten, aber ja,
  • Alle Probleme mit der Einnahme von Benzonatate mit Robitussin und Mucinex?

    Ich überprüfte Websites mehrere Web mit Wechselwirkungen zwischen Arzneimitteln zu tun und jeder Standort angezeigt keine Probleme mit alle drei zusammengenommen jedoch Apotheke verkaufen würde mich nicht Robitussin mit meinem Rezept für Tesalon Perl
  • machen mich Kann Strattera eine tempature bekommen und erschöpft fühlen?

    Schon spüre ich habe für meine ADD ich immer erschöpft fühlen, mein Arzt sagte, es ist nur wegen meiner unregelmäßigen Schlafrhythmus nehmen Strattera. In letzter Zeit aber habe ich jemals Sinn erkannte ich habe das genommen, aus nicht, wo ich eine t
  • Ich habe seit 4 Jahren auf Atorvastatin gewesen. Seit 2 Monate habe ich Schmerzen in meinem linken Arm Muskeln

    Ich habe seit 4 Jahren auf Atorvastatin gewesen. Seit 2 Monate habe ich Schmerzen in meinem linken Arm Muskeln. Könnte es Nebenwirkung von Atorvastatin sein? Soll ich Atorvastatin Einnahme? http://www.drugs.com/answers/ask/ ----schneiden---- In Antwo
  • Folat - Folat-reiche Lebensmittel

    Folat - Folat-reiche Lebensmittel
    Folat ist ein wichtiges Vitamin, das die meisten Eltern wegen der Assoziation von niedrigen Folsäurespiegel bewusst sind mit Frühgeborenen und Geburtsfehler. Diese Defekte des Gehirns oder des Rückenmarks sind die wichtigsten mit unzureichenden Folat
  • Die gesundheitlichen Vorteile von Erdnüsse und Erdnussbutter

    Die gesundheitlichen Vorteile von Erdnüsse und Erdnussbutter
    Sowohl Erdnüsse und Erdnussbutter können Teil einer gesunden Ernährung sein - auch wenn Sie versuchen, Gewicht zu verlieren. Eine Handvoll Erdnüsse ist eine gute Quelle für Eiweiß, Ballaststoffen, einfach ungesättigte Fettsäuren, Niacin, Folsäure und
  • Gibt es eine lipidsenkende Arzneimittel anstelle von Pravastatin?

    Ich habe zum Verlust von Muskel Verwendung auf Lipitor hatte. Ich begann vor kurzem unter Pravachol und habe Kopfschmerzen und plötzliche Auftreten von arthritischen Symptome (geschwollene Gelenke und Schmerzen). Gibt es andere Medikamente wirksam al
  • Mitarbeiter Auswertungen in der Langzeitpflege

    Mitarbeiter Auswertungen in der Langzeitpflege
    Long Term Care ist für hohe Fluktuationsraten bekannt, vor allem bei CNA. Allerdings, wenn Sie für fit mieten können Sie die Chancen erhöhen, dass wird es weniger Personal sein Umdrehen. Und wenn Sie konsequent Personal Auswertungen in der Langzeitpf
  • Lehre Kinder Good Table Manners

    Lehre Kinder Good Table Manners
    Egal, ob Sie zu Hause sind Essen, im Restaurant zu essen, oder beim Abendessen mit Freunden, gute Tischmanieren für Kinder sind ein wichtiger Bestandteil jeder Mahlzeit. Wenn Sie Ihr Kind gute Tischmanieren beibringen, werden Sie sie wichtige Werkzeu