Index · Artikel · Germany resumes ritual circumcisions after bitter dispute

Germany resumes ritual circumcisions after bitter dispute

2012-10-01 8
   
Advertisement
résuméBERLIN Shopkeeper Nevzat Cavan is rushing to meet orders for the white, fur-trimmed costumes worn by Muslim boys for their circumcision, relieved that Berlin's city government has allowed the operations to resume. For three months, the elaborate suit
Advertisement

Germany resumes ritual circumcisions after bitter dispute


BERLIN Shopkeeper Nevzat Cavan is rushing to meet orders for the white, fur-trimmed costumes worn by Muslim boys for their circumcision, relieved that Berlin's city government has allowed the operations to resume.

For three months, the elaborate suits, capes and oriental slippers languished unsold due to a shock court ruling that raised the possibility of criminal charges being brought against families who had their sons circumcised.

"There were days when we didn't even open the till, but now the phone never stops ringing," Turkish-born Cavan said.

The Cologne court ruling in June outraged Germany's Muslims and Jews, and triggered an anguished national debate, by stating that ritual circumcision of under-aged boys amounted to "bodily harm" and parents should wait for their son to make his own decision.

The ruling applied only to the Cologne area but Jews and Muslims across Germany feared it would create a legal precedent, and doctors fearing prosecution stopped performing operations.

Jewish and Muslim groups branded the court order an attack on their religious freedom and an embarrassed German government - particularly sensitive to charges of intolerance because of the Nazi past - vowed to bring in legislation swiftly to protect ritual circumcisions.

Germany is home to about 4 million Muslims, mostly of Turkish origin, and 120,000 Jews. Chancellor Angela Merkel said if it failed to take action it risked becoming a laughing stock.

Anticipating the new law, Berlin authorities announced last month that families circumcising their sons had no reason to fear prosecution and Cavan began to sell his costumes again.

"Those judges in Cologne had no idea about the ramifications of their ruling," said Cavan, whose own grandson's circumcision had to be postponed.

In his shop 'Kids Elegance' in the mainly ethnic Turkish district of Kreuzberg, Cavan sells suits from 85 euros and brightly colored party dresses and festive clothing for siblings, underlining how important circumcision is to Muslim families and the style with which it is celebrated.

DAMAGING DEBATE

The Justice Ministry has now issued the outlines of the new legislation that will protect a family's right to circumcise their child, provided they have been fully informed about the procedure and use the "most effective pain relief possible".

Completion and approval of the new law, which gives any family the right to have their child circumcised, regardless of religion, may be just weeks away. Some lawmakers are pressing for a vote of conscience freed from party discipline.

Muslim and Jewish groups have cautiously welcomed the outline proposal, but the months of uncertainty and debate that followed the Cologne ruling - which triggered rare joint demonstrations - have shaken the communities.

"This whole row has been very damaging to the integration process," said Cologne doctor Omar Kezze.

Kezze, originally from Aleppo in Syria, is the doctor whose trial sparked the Cologne court ruling. A boy he circumcised was taken to hospital after his wounds continued to bleed and the hospital informed the police and local prosecutors. The court cleared Kezze of all charges but created a legal minefield when it classified circumcision as "bodily harm".

"We have a financial crisis, we have extremists on the left and the right, many, many attacks," Kezze said, speaking in his busy surgery where pictures of his native city adorn the wall.

"There are many things for our prosecutors to fight; they really shouldn't be questioning a tradition dating back to Abraham."

"BODILY INTEGRITY"

He welcomed Germany's new proposal but questioned one aspect, which states that only infants below the age of six months can be circumcised by an individual other than a doctor.

This accommodates the Jewish mohel, an individual specially trained in circumcising, but could prevent Muslims from using similar specialists who are not doctors. In Judaism, boys can be circumcised from eight days old; for Muslims the age of the child varies according to family, country and branch of Islam.

"This difference must be revised in the interest of fair treatment," Nurhan Soykan, general secretary of the German Central Council of Muslims, said in a statement.

Not all in Germany want to allow religious circumcisions. An opinion poll by TNS Emnid shortly after the Cologne ruling found 56 percent opposed to the practice.

Some doctors and children's rights associations submitted a petition in September calling for a two-year moratorium and a round-table of medical, religious and legal experts to study circumcision fully.

"In the clear opinion of experts, the amputation of the foreskin is a grave interference in the bodily integrity of a child," Georg Ehrmann, chairman of the child protection group Deutsche Kinderhilfe, told a news conference.

The dispute has also exposed deeper concerns about the status of religious minorities in Germany.

In an editorial in Germany's Sueddeutsche Zeitung entitled "Do you still want us Jews?", Jewish leader Charlotte Knobloch expressed the fury and despair of her community.

"I seriously ask myself whether Germany still wants us," she wrote. "I ask myself whether these know-it-alls from the world of medicine, law, psychology or politics who rant about 'child torture' or 'trauma' have any idea that, in doing this, they call into question the existence of Germany's tiny Jewish presence."

Ender Cetin, community chairman for Berlin's Sehitlik Mosque, said the debates had been saddening.

"We are yet again thrown into the spotlight and forced to defend ourselves ... This only exacerbates prejudice against us."

(Editing by Gareth Jones and Kevin Liffey)

  • Germany resumes ritual circumcisions after bitter dispute

    Germany resumes ritual circumcisions after bitter dispute
    BERLIN Shopkeeper Nevzat Cavan is rushing to meet orders for the white, fur-trimmed costumes worn by Muslim boys for their circumcision, relieved that Berlin's city government has allowed the operations to resume. For three months, the elaborate suit
    2012-10-01 GERMANYCIRCUMCISION
  • Bris Schuld: Beanspruchen der Mutterrolle in einem Ritual Circumcision

    Bris Schuld: Beanspruchen der Mutterrolle in einem Ritual Circumcision
    Nicht ablenken lassen. Ihr Sohn kreischend schreit dienen als akute Erinnerung daran , dass Ihr Baby jetzt ein Teil von etwas jenseits der Gebärmutter ist. Schlafentzug, hob ich meine undicht, geschwollene Brüste in die dritte nicht-Mutterschaft-aber
    2011-12-16
  • California governor prevents ban on male circumcision

    California governor prevents ban on male circumcision
    LOS ANGELES California Governor Jerry Brown has signed a bill preventing local authorities from banning the practice of male circumcision. The bill, which takes effect immediately, comes in the wake of an effort by a San Francisco group opposed to ma
  • Germany's fear of 'chlorine chicken' complicates U.S. trade talks

    Germany's fear of 'chlorine chicken' complicates U.S. trade talks
    BRUSSELS Chancellor Angela Merkel once said she wished "for nothing more than a free-trade agreement between the USA and the EU". To the dismay of many in Brussels and Washington, Germans are now taking a very different view. That is putting Eur
    2014-07-14 USAGERMANYTRADE
  • Circumcision tied to lower prostate cancer risk

    Circumcision tied to lower prostate cancer risk
    NEW YORK (Reuters Health) - Circumcised men may have a slightly lower risk of developing prostate cancer than those who still have their foreskin, according to a new study. The World Health Organization already recommends the controversial procedure
    2012-03-12 CANCERCIRCUMCISION
  • Heute in der Forschung: The Case for Circumcision; Welt Tallest Man

    Heute in der Forschung: The Case for Circumcision;  Welt Tallest Man
    Entdeckt: Die Temperatur , bei der grönländischen Eisdecke verschwinden wird, ein Fall für die Beschneidung, eine sehr präzise 3-D - Drucktechnik und der größte Mann der Welt wird nicht höher wachsen. . Ein Fall für die Beschneidung In Anbetracht die
    2012-03-13
  • Germany faces chickenpox jab shortage after GSK problems

    Germany faces chickenpox jab shortage after GSK problems
    FRANKFURT German doctors have been told to ration two chickenpox vaccines for children after drugmaker GlaxoSmithKline stopped deliveries, saying production quality standards had not been met. Healthcare regulators have issued guidelines to physician
    2014-01-27 VACCINEGLAXO
  • Wie ähnlich ist FGM nach Male Circumcision? Ihre Gedanken

    Wie ähnlich ist FGM nach Male Circumcision?  Ihre Gedanken
    Im vergangenen Monat im Atlantik, Interview Olga Khazan mit Anthropologin Bettina Shell-Duncan auf häufige Missverständnisse der weiblichen Beschneidung auch die weibliche Genitalverstümmelung (FGM) oder die weibliche Genitalbeschneidung (FGC) genann
    2015-05-13
  • Kann Rituals Helfen Sie uns mit Trauer Deal?

    Kann Rituals Helfen Sie uns mit Trauer Deal?
    Es ist sicher zu sagen, dass Trauer universell ist. Jeder erfährt Verlust, sei es der Verlust eines geliebten Menschen, das Ende einer Liebesbeziehung, oder jede Art von einem schweren Rückschlag im Leben. Der Prozess der Umgang wiith dieser Trauer o
    2015-11-23
  • Germany looks set to abstain in EU glyphosate vote

    Germany looks set to abstain in EU glyphosate vote
    BERLIN/BRUSSELS Germany looks set to abstain in a European Union vote next week on the continued use of glyphosate in weed killers because ministries run by different parties remain at odds over the chemical which some experts say could be carcinogen
    2016-05-12 HEALTHGLYPHOSATE
  • Kochen und Liebend Bitter Herbs

    Kochen und Liebend Bitter Herbs
    Foto von Aglaia Kremezi "Ich frage mich , ob du Griechen essen auch die Sachen , die aus den Ohren kommt ..." , rief Koch Rick Moonen , mit nur ein Stück von eingelegtem volvos --wild Hyazinthen Zwiebel (lampascioni in italienischer Sprache) aus
    2009-05-05
  • Circumcision helps protect men, not women from AIDS

    Circumcision helps protect men, not women from AIDS
    WASHINGTON Circumcision may help protect men from the AIDS virus but it does not protect the wives and female partners of infected men, researchers reported on Thursday. The disappointed researchers had to stop the trial, which they had hoped would c
    2009-07-17 AIDSCIRCUMCISION
  • Kann Salz Hilfe bei der Gallenstein Patient Bitter?

    einer der Patienten, der an den Gallensteinen, nahm Epsom Salz, und nach vielen Monaten berichtet, dass er keine Steine ​​in der Gallen hat. so meine Frage ist wirklich Bittersalz auf den Gallensteinen arbeitet. bitte meine Frage beantworten .. ----s
  • A Bitter Thai Cuisine, Gewürzt durch die Vergangenheit

    A Bitter Thai Cuisine, Gewürzt durch die Vergangenheit
    Jarrett Wrisley Jarrett Rezept gaeng om Um zu versuchen, ein soupy, Kräuter Thai Curry gegrilltes Fleisch oder Reis begleiten, klicken Sie hier. Wie ich aus einem mit Gras gefüttert Kuh in einem blassen, rosa Filet geschnitten, mein Thai Freund Pim l
    2010-03-11
  • U.S. resumes funding controversial stem cell research

    U.S. resumes funding controversial stem cell research
    WASHINGTON The U.S. government said it was resuming work on controversial human embryonic stem cell research on Friday after an appeals court ruled in its favor. In the latest legal back-and-forth on the issue, a U.S. appeals court on Thursday grante
    2010-09-10 USASTEMCELLS
  • Germany finds dioxin in pork as well as poultry

    Germany finds dioxin in pork as well as poultry
    BERLIN/HAMBURG German authorities said on Tuesday the highly toxic chemical dioxin had been discovered in pork in addition to poultry products, which would expand the scope of a current health alert. German and European Union authorities are dealing
    2011-01-11 GERMANYDIOXIN
  • Dioxin-tainted pork possibly sold in Germany

    Dioxin-tainted pork possibly sold in Germany
    HAMBURG Pork tainted with the highly toxic chemical dioxin may have been sold in Germany, authorities said on Wednesday. German and European Union authorities are struggling to contain a health alert which began on January 3 when German officials sai
    2011-01-12 GERMANYDIOXIN
  • Germany announces anti-dioxin action plan

    Germany announces anti-dioxin action plan
    HAMBURG Germany on Friday announced a plan to enforce higher standards in animal feed production after the discovery of the toxic chemical dioxin in feed, which has triggered a health alert and hit sales of German eggs and pork. German and European U
    2011-01-14 ACTIONDIOXINPLAN
  • Germany declares end to E. coli outbreak

    Germany declares end to E. coli outbreak
    BERLIN Germany's federal disease control institute declared on Tuesday that an E. coli outbreak which killed more than 50 people is now over and no cases have been reported in the past three weeks. More than 4,400 people in Europe and North America w
    2011-07-26 GERMANYECOLI
  • San Francisco zu entscheiden, auf Male Circumcision

    San Francisco zu entscheiden, auf Male Circumcision
    Als in den 1930er Jahren, schottische Missionare die britische Kolonialregierung von Kenia ermutigt die Beschneidung von Frauen zu verbieten, nahm die Mutter einer Freundin von uns, zusammen mit Hunderten von afrikanischen Frauen, auf die Straße zu p
    2012-01-01

TOP

  • Day/
  • Week/
  • Original/
  • Recommand

Updated