Index · Artikel · Analysis: Investors weigh chaos as high court reviews health law

Analysis: Investors weigh chaos as high court reviews health law

2012-03-22 7
   
Advertisement
résuméNEW YORK At Aetna Inc's headquarters in Hartford, Connecticut, about two dozen employees devote all their working hours to one task: making sure the health insurer is up to speed with President Barack Obama's U.S. healthcare overhaul law. On a part-t
Advertisement

Analysis: Investors weigh chaos as high court reviews health law


NEW YORK At Aetna Inc's headquarters in Hartford, Connecticut, about two dozen employees devote all their working hours to one task: making sure the health insurer is up to speed with President Barack Obama's U.S. healthcare overhaul law.

On a part-time basis, more than 1,000 more employees are also working daily on activities tied to the overhaul as the No. 3 U.S. health insurer seeks to comply with the regulations and communicates the changes to its thousands of customers.

In 2010 alone, Aetna says it invested 53,000 work hours -- the equivalent of one person working for 25 years -- updating computer systems to accommodate the new benefits and changes in the law.

"This is touching every different type of business we have," Kay Mooney, Aetna's head of strategic development and product who is helping oversee the company's overhaul efforts, said in an interview. "We need to think about it in all respects."

What if all the work is for naught? That possibility comes into high relief for the healthcare industry starting on Monday, when the U.S. Supreme Court begins hearing arguments about the healthcare overhaul law.

And it has investors and analysts attempting to handicap fallout from the high-profile decision. Shares of large health insurers appear to face little significant downside should the law be entirely tossed out or upheld -- at least in the near term. The major risk lies with a decision that strikes down just the part of the law that requires people to buy coverage.

The court is expected to rule by late June on the law -- Obama's signature domestic policy achievement enacted two years ago that is set to extend health coverage to more than 30 million uninsured Americans. The law is being challenged by 26 states and an independent business group.

At the heart of the court debate is the portion that requires individuals to buy health insurance or pay a penalty. Should the court strike down that requirement, known as the individual mandate, and deem it unseverable from the rest of the law, the entire legislation would be invalidated.

"We will have chaos," said Timothy Jost, a law professor who focuses on healthcare at the Washington and Lee University School of Law in Virginia.

Such chaos may not be bad news for investors in the short term. Many healthcare analysts say shares of large insurers, such as Aetna, UnitedHealth Group Inc and WellPoint Inc stand to immediately jump at least 5 percent should the court strike down the legislation as a whole.

Others see a more modest insurer share rally possible if the law is upheld as a decision will provide more certainty over how the companies will do business. But most agree that a partial ruling that tosses out just the individual mandate could be disastrous for the stocks.

The law's regulations put greater scrutiny on the insurance premium increases that help fuel industry profits. They require insurers to spend at least 80 percent of their premiums on medical costs as opposed to administrative expenses and impose higher fees on their insurance plans in the years ahead.

"The best case is if the whole thing gets thrown out," said Tim Nelson, healthcare analyst with Nuveen Asset Management.

But that sentiment has not been shared by many insurance executives since the law was passed in 2010. Several have expressed their opposition to Republican efforts to repeal the law. If the Supreme Court shoots it down now, the problems of Americans lacking insurance and the country's rising healthcare costs will remain -- possibly forcing government to intervene with far more onerous regulations on the industry in the future.

"What the marketplace needs is some certainty as to where healthcare reform is going," said Robert Laszewski, who consults for health insurers as president of Health Policy and Strategy Associates. "And while the Obama health law is so imperfect and flawed in so many ways, it gave us a target and it said here's where we're going to be for the next 10 or 20 years."

Among other industries, shares of hospital chains, such as HCA Holdings Inc and Tenet Healthcare Inc, are expected to drop steeply should the law be struck down because they would stand to lose millions of insured customers.

Such a ruling is poised to boost shares of medical device manufacturers, such as Boston Scientific, which face taxes on sales of their products under the law.

STATUS QUO SEEN LIKELY

In an American Bar Association poll of a small group of influential academics, journalists and lawyers who follow the Supreme Court, 85 percent predicted the law would be upheld.

More than 70 percent of 200 investors queried by Goldman Sachs in January also speculated that a decision to uphold the law would be the most likely outcome.

Still, shares of health insurers could rise modestly should the law win backing. Some investors may have held off on the sector until the court's decision provides more certainty.

"If it's status quo, there's probably a rally," said Les Funtleyder, a portfolio manager and healthcare strategist with Miller Tabak. "It's probably also a rally for hospitals too."

The worst-case scenario for health insurers is if the court strikes down the individual mandate but leaves the rest of the law standing. Wall Street experts see this as unlikely.

The law requires insurers to offer coverage regardless of health status, including pre-existing medical conditions. To counter the likely influx of sick, high-cost policyholders, insurers say the individual mandate is necessary to ensure that healthy people are also in the insurance pool.

If only the mandate is struck down, many people may only buy insurance when they become ill, said Justine Handelman, vice president of legislative and regulatory policy for the Blue Cross and Blue Shield Association.

"It's akin to saying you can buy your homeowners insurance when you smell smoke," Handelman said. "That will cause premiums to go up for everyone."

Health insurer stocks would also tumble, possibly more than 5 percent, said David Heupel, senior healthcare analyst at Thrivent Investment Management.

The court is also weighing whether the federal government unconstitutionally forced the states to expand the Medicaid program to millions more low-income Americans under the law.

The expansion could provide an important growth opportunity for some big players like UnitedHealth as well as smaller insurers that specialize in Medicaid, such as Amerigroup, Molina Healthcare and Centene.

"We believe Medicaid's expansion ... is the one that carries a meaningful risk of being overturned," analysts at Jefferies & Co said in a recent research note. "Such a decision would be a meaningful negative for most healthcare service stocks, especially acute care providers and managed Medicaid companies."

Meanwhile, Aetna and other insurers continue to operate as if the law will stay in place -- unless they learn otherwise.

"We have strategies ready for whatever happens over the next 18 months," Mooney said.

(Editing by Michele Gershberg; desking by Mark Porter)

TOP

  • Day/
  • Week/
  • Original/
  • Recommand

Updated

  • H1N1 might have peaked in Canada

    H1N1 might have peaked in Canada
    TORONTO Canadian health officials said on Wednesday that the H1N1 flu outbreak might have reached its peak in Canada, but cautioned that the fight is not yet over. David Butler-Jones, Canada's chief public health officer, said that while some areas o
  • Abilify 2mg bis 5 mg, was mich schlecht schütteln?

    Ich habe für 2 Wochen auf abilify gewesen, 2 mg. mein Doc gestern Abend zu mir meine Dosis auf 5 mg .. worden Schütteln und müde den ganzen Tag wollten. Hatte einen bipolaren Zusammenbruch ersten Mal in zwei Wochen früher .. Es scheint, die 2 mg funk
  • Medtronic startet Schock-Reduzierung Defibrillator in Europa

    Medtronic startet Schock-Reduzierung Defibrillator in Europa
    Medtronic Inc. (NYSE: MDT) hat in Europa eine Reihe von implantierbaren Kardioverter-Defibrillatoren ins Leben gerufen, die eine unnötige Schocks reduzieren sollen zu. Die companyâ € ™ s Protecta ICDs und kardialen Resynchronisationstherapie - Geräte
  • Childbirth takes longer now than 50 years ago: study

    Childbirth takes longer now than 50 years ago: study
    n">Many tasks can be tackled more quickly now than 50 years ago, but delivering a baby naturally it seems is not one of them, according to a U.S. government study. Compared with the 1960s, U.S. women have in recent years spent two to three hours l
  • Reis und Arsen, Babys Warnung und der Rest von uns?

    Hallo alle. Hoffnung, die Menschen fangen die Nachrichten in Bezug auf die Arsengehalt in Reis, der in den USA und der Gefahr, die sie für Säuglinge, beeinträchtigtem Immunsystem und Menschen mit häufigen Konsum stellt angebaut wird. Offenbar weiß Re
  • Mein Seroquel XR in der Nacht hat scheinen völlig arbeiten zu beenden. Verwendet schläfrig zu werden und rechts fallen?

    ... Zu schlafen und die ganze Nacht schlafen. Jetzt nicht sleeply und die ganze Nacht aufwachen. Gerade erst eröffnet eine neue Flasche und scheint zufällig. Jeder sonst dieses Problem haben? Vielen Dank ----schneiden---- In Antwort auf Delila bei 20
  • Draft EU rules to open door to plain cigarette packets

    Draft EU rules to open door to plain cigarette packets
    BRUSSELS The European Union's executive Commission is to propose larger health warnings on cigarette packets and a total ban on flavorings such as menthol, a draft revision of EU tobacco rules seen by Reuters showed on Monday. The proposals stop shor
  • Natrium-Leitlinien werden müssen neu überdacht ", sagen Experten

    Natrium-Leitlinien werden müssen neu überdacht ", sagen Experten
    Credit: Africa Studio / Shutterstock.com Menschen, deren Ernährung enthalten moderate Mengen an Natrium gesündere Herzen haben und länger leben als diejenigen, die zu viel verbrauchen oder zu wenig von dem Mineral, schlägt neue Forschung. In einer gr
  • Beliebte Dystopische Burrito Kampagne Impliziert Chipotle ist keine riesige Fastfood-Kette

    Beliebte Dystopische Burrito Kampagne Impliziert Chipotle ist keine riesige Fastfood-Kette
    [Youtube] lUtnas5ScSE [/ youtube] Letzte Woche Chipotle veröffentlicht diese als Marketing-Kampagne kurz animiert. Seiten wie The New York Times, NPR, Schiefer, etc. veröffentlicht das Video, die meisten mit glühenden Vermerke (Bruce Horovitz bei USA
  • Wie ein Food Journal zu machen, und warum

    Wie ein Food Journal zu machen, und warum
    ein Ernährungstagebuch zu halten, ist eine besonders leistungsstarke Praxis, die Ihre Ernährung verwandeln kann. Nur durch Ihr Maß an Bewusstsein über das Essen und Ihre Essgewohnheiten zu erheben, kann ein Ernährungstagebuch hilft Ihnen mehr gesund